Does neck stage influence local control in squamous cell carcinomas of the head and neck?

Recently, reports have suggested that the probability of local control of head and neck cancers treated with radiotherapy alone is inversely related to the extent of neck node disease at presentation. This has led some to conclude that primary lesions in patients with neck node metastases should be treated more aggressively than lesions of the same T stage in patients presenting with a clinically negative neck. We reviewed the records of 607 patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck to determine the relationship between the extent of neck node disease at diagnosis and the probability of tumor control at the primary site. All patients were treated with continuous-course irradiation alone to the primary site and have a minimum follow-up of 2 years. Mucosal sites analyzed included the oropharynx (soft palate, tonsillar region, base of tongue), hypopharynx (pharyngeal wall, pyriform sinus), and supraglottic larynx. Patients with simultaneous primary lesions were excluded from the analysis. Parameters tested included T stage, N stage, and fractionation (once daily or twice daily). For statistical analyses, N stage was grouped as N0, N1, N2A-N3A, and N2B-N3B. Local control was analyzed using a multivariate analysis, the forward stepwise long-rank test of association of covariates. Multivariate analyses revealed that the following parameters significantly influenced local control: oropharynx, T stage only (p = .0010); hypopharynx, T stage (p = .001) and twice-daily fractionation (p = .0031); and supraglottic larynx, T stage only (p = .0002). No significant correlation was found between neck stage and primary tumor control on univariate or multivariate analyses. Our data do not support the conclusion that primary lesions are controlled less often in patients with clinically positive neck nodes.