An evaluation of the provocative tests for superior labral anterior posterior lesions.

BACKGROUND

Although our understanding of superior labral anterior posterior lesions has grown, the physical diagnosis remains imperfect.

STUDY DESIGN

Cohort study (diagnostic); Level of evidence, 2.

PURPOSE

To determine the most effective provocative maneuver with which to diagnose superior labral anterior posterior lesions.

METHODS

A series of 132 consecutive patients scheduled to undergo diagnostic shoulder arthroscopy were examined preoperatively over a 6-month period, and the final diagnosis in each case was made arthroscopically. The following assessments were included: active compression (O'Brien), anterior slide, pain provocation, crank, Jobe relocation, Hawkins, Neer, Speed, and Yergason tests.

RESULTS

The most sensitive diagnostic tools for type II superior labral lesions were the active compression, Hawkins, Speed, Neer, and Jobe relocation tests. When type I and type II lesions were combined, the results were similar. However, none of the sensitive tests were specific for either type I or type II lesions.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors' results contradict the current literature regarding provocative testing for both stable and unstable superior labral lesions. There is no single maneuver that can accurately diagnose superior labral anterior posterior lesions; arthroscopy remains the standard by which to diagnose such lesions.