Ogle Karen S, Mavis Brian, Thomason Clayton
Department of Family Practice, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan 48824, USA.
J Palliat Med. 2005 Oct;8(5):987-97. doi: 10.1089/jpm.2005.8.987.
A statewide survey of postgraduate medical training programs was conducted to determine the current status of training related to end-of-life (EOL) care and hospice care training.
A mail survey of 275 program directors was conducted with a response rate of 70%. The questionnaire focused on information about training in EOL care and hospice care: specific content, required and elective experiences, teaching formats, and program directors' ratings of the perceived adequacy of training. This study received Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval.
Less than half (46%) of the residency programs reported any formal training in EOL care, and less than one third (31%) reported training in hospice care. A majority of programs with EOL and/or hospice training required it for all residents. Of the programs with required hospice training, only half included a clinical component; fewer programs with EOL training reported a clinical component. Most program directors rated their programs as adequate or excellent in terms of EOL and hospice care, whether they had formal training or not.
The results of the survey demonstrate considerable variability in training with respect to hospice and EOL care. Training through direct clinical experience was infrequently reported. There has been little formal adoption of published curricula in this area. The high level of adequacy in the rating of training by program directors contrasts with relative lack of reported curriculum content and implementation, suggesting that improvements in EOL care training will be slow to come if left in the hands of program directors.
开展一项针对全州研究生医学培训项目的调查,以确定与临终关怀(EOL)护理及临终关怀培训相关的当前培训状况。
对275名项目主任进行邮件调查,回复率为70%。调查问卷聚焦于EOL护理及临终关怀培训的相关信息:具体内容、必修和选修经历、教学形式以及项目主任对培训感知充分性的评级。本研究获得了机构审查委员会(IRB)的批准。
不到一半(46%)的住院医师培训项目报告有任何正式的EOL护理培训,不到三分之一(31%)报告有临终关怀培训。大多数开展EOL和/或临终关怀培训的项目要求所有住院医师参加。在要求进行临终关怀培训的项目中,只有一半包含临床部分;开展EOL培训的项目中报告有临床部分的较少。无论是否有正式培训,大多数项目主任对其项目在EOL和临终关怀护理方面的评价为充分或优秀。
调查结果表明,临终关怀和EOL护理培训存在很大差异。很少有报告称通过直接临床经验进行培训。该领域很少正式采用已发表的课程。项目主任对培训的高度充分性评价与所报告的课程内容和实施相对缺乏形成对比,这表明如果由项目主任负责,EOL护理培训的改进将进展缓慢。