Dinakar Chitra, Adams Christina, Brimer Alysa, Silva Maria D
Section of Allergy/Asthma/Immunology, Children's Mercy Hospital, University of Missouri, Kansas City, Missouri 64108, USA.
J Asthma. 2005 Oct;42(8):683-7. doi: 10.1080/02770900500265157.
People learn in different ways: visually, aurally, by reading/writing, and kinesthetically. In our clinic, we use color-coded Asthma Action Cards to educate our patients and their caregivers on asthma management. Our teaching is largely aural based, with the cards providing reading and visual stimulation and hands-on practice with devices offering kinesthetic stimulation.
We sought to determine the learning styles of the caregivers of our asthmatic children.
Caregivers in our Asthma/Allergy Clinic completed the Visual-Aural-Read/Write-Kinesthetic (VARK) questionnaire anonymously, and the responses were evaluated on the basis of previously validated scoring instructions.
Analysis of 98 respondents showed that 42% had a single learning modality preference, and the remaining 58% were multimodal learners. Of those who reported a single mode of learning, 61% preferred kinesthetic, 27% preferred reading/writing, and less than 1% each preferred aural or visual stimuli. Of all 98 caregivers, 82% included kinesthetic as a learning preference, 59% included read/write, 50% included aural, and 41% included visual.
The majority of caregivers preferred the kinesthetic learning method, whether as a single learning preference or in combination with other approaches. Incorporating kinesthetic methods of learning, such as role plays and problem-solving case scenarios, into standardized asthma education curricula may be beneficial to patients and families in terms of understanding and using their regimen.
人们有不同的学习方式:视觉、听觉、阅读/写作以及动觉。在我们的诊所,我们使用颜色编码的哮喘行动计划卡来教育患者及其护理人员如何管理哮喘。我们的教学主要基于听觉,卡片提供阅读和视觉刺激,而使用设备进行的实践操作则提供动觉刺激。
我们试图确定哮喘患儿护理人员的学习方式。
我们哮喘/过敏诊所的护理人员匿名填写了视觉-听觉-阅读/写作-动觉(VARK)问卷,并根据先前验证的评分说明对回答进行评估。
对98名受访者的分析表明,42%的人有单一的学习方式偏好,其余58%是多模态学习者。在报告单一学习方式的人中,61%偏好动觉,27%偏好阅读/写作,偏好听觉或视觉刺激的各不到1%。在所有98名护理人员中,82%将动觉列为学习偏好,59%包括阅读/写作,50%包括听觉,41%包括视觉。
大多数护理人员更喜欢动觉学习方法,无论是作为单一的学习偏好还是与其他方法结合使用。将动觉学习方法,如角色扮演和解决问题的案例场景,纳入标准化的哮喘教育课程,可能有助于患者及其家庭理解和使用他们的治疗方案。