Wallace Neal T, Bloom Joan R, Hu Teh-Wei, Libby Anne M
Division of Public Administration of the Mark O. Hatfield School of Government, Portland State University, P.O. Box 751, Portland, Oregon 97207-0751, USA.
Psychiatr Serv. 2005 Nov;56(11):1402-8. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.56.11.1402.
This study investigated the impact of Colorado's Medicaid mental health managed care program on patterns of antipsychotic medication treatment among persons with a diagnosis of schizophrenia. These patterns were compared with patterns of psychosocial treatment and a measure of symptom change.
Changes in study measures over time in two areas of the state where the policy intervention was implemented were compared with changes in measures in areas where it was not implemented. The study sample consisted of 235 consumers. Measures of antipsychotic medication treatment included any use in a given period, months in which a prescription was filled, and use of second-generation antipsychotics. Psychosocial treatment was measured by any use and expenditures per user. The schizophrenia subscale of the Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale was used to measure consumer outcomes.
Probabilities of antipsychotic use in the managed care areas were stable or increased compared with the other areas. The average number of months with filled prescriptions was unchanged. Consumers served under managed care were less likely to use psychosocial treatment, and additional decreases in treatment costs were noted in one area. Difference scores for the schizophrenia subscale showed no change or positive effects for the managed care areas.
Within the Colorado managed care program, antipsychotic medication therapy was not impaired, despite significant decreases in the continuity or intensity of psychosocial treatment, and no reduction in symptom levels was noted. Mental health managed care does not inherently impair medication therapy. Patterns of medication use appeared to be better indicators of program success than psychosocial treatment patterns and were more consistent with outcomes.
本研究调查了科罗拉多州医疗补助心理健康管理式医疗项目对被诊断为精神分裂症患者的抗精神病药物治疗模式的影响。将这些模式与心理社会治疗模式及症状变化指标进行比较。
将政策干预实施地区两个区域内研究指标随时间的变化与未实施地区指标的变化进行比较。研究样本包括235名消费者。抗精神病药物治疗指标包括特定时期内的任何使用情况、开具处方的月数以及第二代抗精神病药物的使用情况。心理社会治疗通过任何使用情况及每位使用者的支出进行衡量。使用简明精神病评定量表的精神分裂症分量表来衡量消费者的治疗结果。
与其他地区相比,管理式医疗地区使用抗精神病药物的可能性保持稳定或有所增加。开具处方的平均月数没有变化。接受管理式医疗的消费者接受心理社会治疗的可能性较小,且在一个区域发现治疗成本进一步降低。精神分裂症分量表的差异分数显示,管理式医疗地区没有变化或有积极影响。
在科罗拉多州的管理式医疗项目中,尽管心理社会治疗的连续性或强度显著下降,但抗精神病药物治疗并未受到影响,且未观察到症状水平降低。心理健康管理式医疗本身不会损害药物治疗。与心理社会治疗模式相比,药物使用模式似乎是项目成功的更好指标,且与治疗结果更一致。