Montserrat M Ramos
Gabinete Técnico, Atención Primaria de Mallorca, Mallorca, España.
Aten Primaria. 2005 Nov;36(8):462-5. doi: 10.1157/13081062.
To compare the effectiveness of group advanced intervention and individual advanced intervention for smoking management in primary health care; b) to know if in group intervention exists an added positive effect due of the group and, if this is true, to characterize it; and c) to know the advantages and inconvenients that the participants attribute to each intervention.
Control clinic trial randomized in individual scale.
Mallorca primary health centers, Spain.
Smokers >5 packet-year or monoxid carbon levels >15 ppm prepared for give up smoking. People younger than 18 years, people with terminal illness, and mental problems will be excluded.
Candidates will be assigned to: a) group intervention; b) individual intervention; or c) short intervention or control group. Interventions will be done by a nurse and a general practitioner. Depth interview will be done for qualitative study. PRINCIPAL MEASUREMENT: Maintained cessation during 12 months confirmed by expired-air carbon monoxide measurement. SECONDARY MEASUREMENTS: Self-declared cessation and confirmed by expired-air carbon monoxide measurement months 1, 2, 3, 6, and 9, and tobacco reduction if there isn't abandonment.
Intention treatment. Multilevel analysis will be done to determinate the positive effect added of the group if it's proved that exists. Content analysis for qualitative study.
Randomization will prevent participants will be treated by their general practitioner o their nurse, this can mean worse results than results obtained in practice.
a)比较初级卫生保健中团体强化干预和个体强化干预对吸烟管理的效果;b)了解团体干预中是否因团体因素存在额外的积极效果,若存在,对其进行特征描述;c)了解参与者认为每种干预的优缺点。
个体层面的随机对照临床试验。
西班牙马略卡岛的初级卫生保健中心。
吸烟量超过5包年或一氧化碳水平超过15 ppm且准备戒烟的吸烟者。排除18岁以下人群、患有绝症者和有精神问题者。
将候选人分配至:a)团体干预;b)个体干预;或c)短期干预或对照组。干预由一名护士和一名全科医生进行。将进行深度访谈以进行定性研究。主要测量指标:通过呼出气体一氧化碳测量确认12个月内保持戒烟状态。次要测量指标:在第1、2、3、6和9个月自我宣称戒烟并经呼出气体一氧化碳测量确认,若未戒烟则测量烟草减量情况。
意向性治疗分析。若证明团体干预存在额外积极效果,将进行多水平分析以确定其大小。对定性研究进行内容分析。
随机分组将避免参与者由其全科医生或护士进行治疗,这可能意味着结果比实际中获得的结果更差。