Bosset Jean-François, Lorchel F, Mantion G, Buffet J, Créhange G, Bosset M, Chaigneau L, Servagi S
Department of Radiation-Oncology, Besançon University Hospital, Boulevard Fleming, F-25030 Besançon Cedex, France.
J Surg Oncol. 2005 Dec 1;92(3):239-45. doi: 10.1002/jso.20365.
The aims of preoperative chemoradiation therapy (preop-CRT) for esophageal adenocarcinoma are to reduce incomplete local resection (R1,R2), local and systemic recurrences that are reported in up to 30% of patients who undergo surgery alone. Phase II studies of preop-CRT, with radiation doses in the 40-50 Gy range, and concurrent chemotherapy with 5-fluorouracil (5-FU)-cisplatin +/- paclitaxel, or cisplatin-paclitaxel, have reported subsequent RO resection rates of 80%-100%, with tumor sterilization achieved in 8%-49% of cases, and consequently improved local control. New chemotherapy regimens omitting 5-FU have reduced the incidence of severe esophagitis, unplanned hospitalization, with comparable efficacy. Among three randomised trials that compared preop-CRT to surgery alone, one shown a debatable survival advantage. Reducing local recurrence rates lead to a switch to more distant failures, and increasing the radiation dose beyond 45 Gy appears to be of little value. However, it should be remembered that preop-CRT has associated toxicity, and may increase postoperative mortality. Novel strategies, which include induction with chemotherapy followed by preop-CRT, and for radiation therapy, three dimensional conformation techniques, image fusioning, and improved definition of treatment volumes, are still considered experimental and should be tested in specialized centers.
食管腺癌术前放化疗(preop-CRT)的目的是减少不完全局部切除(R1、R2),以及单独接受手术的患者中高达30%会出现的局部和全身复发。术前放化疗的II期研究中,放疗剂量在40-50 Gy范围内,同时使用5-氟尿嘧啶(5-FU)-顺铂+/-紫杉醇或顺铂-紫杉醇进行化疗,报告显示后续R0切除率为80%-100%,8%-49%的病例实现了肿瘤清除,从而改善了局部控制。新的不含5-FU的化疗方案降低了严重食管炎和非计划住院的发生率,疗效相当。在三项比较术前放化疗与单纯手术的随机试验中,有一项显示出有争议的生存优势。降低局部复发率会导致更多远处转移,将放疗剂量增加到45 Gy以上似乎没有什么价值。然而,应该记住,术前放化疗有相关毒性,可能会增加术后死亡率。新的策略,包括化疗诱导后进行术前放化疗,以及放疗采用三维适形技术、图像融合和改善靶区定义,仍被认为是试验性的,应在专业中心进行测试。