Neri Vincenzo, Ambrosi Antonio, Fersini Alberto, Valentino Tiziano Pio
University of Foggia, Department of Surgical Sciences, Division of General Surgery.
Ann Ital Chir. 2005 Mar-Apr;76(2):123-6.
To compare the results of the laparoscopic adrenalectomy achieved with the traditional laparotomic one.
In the period 1997-September 2004 we treated 17 patients with adrenal pathology: eight patients underwent to an open anterior transperitoneal adrenalectomy and nine patients underwent a laparoscopic adrenalectomy with lateral transperitoneal approach.
Among the immediate results a longer operative time was evident in the laparoscopic approach and a greater blood loss in the open approach; there were no conversions to a laparotomic procedure. In the postoperative period there were some bronchopneumonic infiltrates and some infections of the laparotomy in the open group; in the laparoscopic group there was a parietal haematomas that cleared up spontaneously, in correspondence of a trocar access.
Both procedures allow to achieve the complete resolution of the adrenal pathology if it is confined within the gland and no more than 8 cm. in size. The morbidity in the mininvasive approach is surely much lower than the open technique. The advantages of a laparoscopic approach can be found in a minor surgical stress. The evident datum that results from the literature analysis of the results of the the laparoscopic adrenalectomies, is the very rapid resumption of the normal activities in the postoperative course.
The laparoscopic adrenalectomy with lateral transperitoneal approach is a safe and efficacious procedure. Therefore, the AA can believe that the laparoscopic approach is at present the gold standard in the treatment of all benign adrenal pathologies with a no more than 8 cm. size.
比较腹腔镜肾上腺切除术与传统开腹肾上腺切除术的结果。
在1997年至2004年9月期间,我们治疗了17例肾上腺疾病患者:8例行开放性经腹前肾上腺切除术,9例行腹腔镜肾上腺切除术,采用侧方经腹入路。
在近期结果中,腹腔镜手术入路的手术时间明显更长,而开放手术入路的失血量更大;没有转为开腹手术的情况。术后,开放组出现了一些支气管肺炎浸润和一些剖腹手术切口感染;腹腔镜组在一个套管针穿刺部位出现了腹壁血肿,该血肿自行消退。
如果肾上腺病变局限于腺体内且大小不超过8厘米,两种手术方法都能实现肾上腺病变的完全消除。微创入路的发病率肯定远低于开放技术。腹腔镜手术入路的优势在于手术应激较小。对腹腔镜肾上腺切除术结果进行文献分析得出的明显数据是,术后恢复正常活动非常迅速。
侧方经腹入路的腹腔镜肾上腺切除术是一种安全有效的手术方法。因此,AA可以认为,目前腹腔镜手术入路是治疗所有大小不超过8厘米的良性肾上腺病变的金标准。