Miller Michael, Smith Tony P
Department of Radiology, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC 27710, USA.
Gastroenterol Clin North Am. 2005 Dec;34(4):735-52. doi: 10.1016/j.gtc.2005.09.001.
Diagnostic angiography still plays an essential role in the diagnosis of patients,particularly those with acute lower GI bleeding. Transcatheter therapy appears to be a viable treatment alternative in selected patients with GI bleeding. Many interventionists today believe embolotherapy to be more effective initially and to have better long-term results, specifically less rebleeding, than vasopressin infusion with at least equal complication rates. Unfortunately, direct comparison of the two techniques in a randomized, controlled fashion has not been performed. Small patient series, such as those summarized here, suggest that the results of the two techniques are essentially equal, and ischemic complications appear more prevalent with embolotherapy. The use of embolotherapy--either empirically based on endoscopic or surgical findings or directed against a site found to have contrast extravasation-represents the current intervention of choice in the case of upper GI bleeding refractory to endoscopic intervention. Head-to-head studies directly comparing the efficacy, morbidity, and mortality associated with endovascular or surgical correction of bleeding from the upper GI tract is needed. Although the current tide favors embolotherapy in the lower GI tract, infusion of vasoconstricting agents deserves more attention. To that end, there is a great need for scientific data regarding the safety and efficacy of transcatheter therapy for upper and lower GI bleeding.
诊断性血管造影在患者诊断中仍起着至关重要的作用,尤其是对急性下消化道出血患者。对于部分消化道出血患者,经导管治疗似乎是一种可行的治疗选择。如今,许多介入医生认为,与血管加压素输注相比,栓塞疗法在初始治疗时更有效,且长期效果更好,特别是再出血更少,而两者的并发症发生率至少相当。遗憾的是,尚未以随机对照方式对这两种技术进行直接比较。如本文总结的小型患者系列研究表明,这两种技术的结果基本相同,且栓塞疗法的缺血性并发症似乎更为常见。对于内镜干预难以治疗的上消化道出血,基于内镜或手术结果经验性地使用栓塞疗法,或者针对发现有造影剂外渗的部位进行栓塞治疗,是目前的首选干预措施。需要进行直接比较上消化道出血的血管内或手术矫正的疗效、发病率和死亡率的直接对比研究。尽管目前趋势是在下消化道出血中倾向于栓塞疗法,但血管收缩剂的输注值得更多关注。为此,非常需要有关经导管治疗上、下消化道出血的安全性和有效性的科学数据。