Novotny Jan, Pecen Ladislav, Petruzelka Lubos, Svobodnik Adam, Dusek Ladislav, Danes Jan, Skovajsova Miloslava
Department of Oncology, General Teaching Hospital, Prague, Czech Republic,
Breast Cancer Res Treat. 2006 Jan;95(1):29-35. doi: 10.1007/s10549-005-9027-5. Epub 2005 Dec 1.
Several mathematical models have been developed for predicting individual breast cancer risk. Such models can help clinicians to choose appropriate preventive and therapeutic interventions for each patient. Unfortunately, the validity of these models has not been tested outside the USA.
The authors describe a case-control study in the Czech Republic with a similar design to that of the US Breast Cancer Detection and Demonstration Project (BCDDP). The main objective of the study was to evaluate the validity of the Gail model in the Czech female population, and to develop a local model using the same statistical approach as the Gail model. Between November 2000 and May 2004, 14,566 questionnaires containing case history data from both healthy women (control group) and women with breast cancer were collected. Case-control age-matched pairs (n = 4598) have subsequently been matched and analyzed.
Our results show that the original Gail model was not able to properly distinguish between controls and breast cancer cases in the Czech female population. Based on paired data, the mean 5-year and life-time breast cancer risk was 1.379 +/- 0.668 and 7.990 +/- 3.184 in the control group and 1.375 +/- 0.692 and 8.028 +/- 3.506 in the patients with breast cancer group. The original Gail model was also not able to properly describe age-specific baseline risk of breast cancer development in the Czech population. In response the authors developed two variants of modified/locally adjusted models.
The original Gail model is not an accurate breast cancer risk assessment tool for the Czech female population.
已经开发了几种数学模型来预测个体患乳腺癌的风险。这些模型可以帮助临床医生为每位患者选择合适的预防和治疗干预措施。不幸的是,这些模型的有效性尚未在美国以外的地区进行测试。
作者描述了在捷克共和国进行的一项病例对照研究,其设计与美国乳腺癌检测与示范项目(BCDDP)相似。该研究的主要目的是评估盖尔模型在捷克女性人群中的有效性,并使用与盖尔模型相同的统计方法开发一个本地模型。在2000年11月至2004年5月期间,收集了14566份问卷,其中包含健康女性(对照组)和乳腺癌女性的病史数据。随后对年龄匹配的病例对照对(n = 4598)进行了匹配和分析。
我们的结果表明,原始的盖尔模型无法在捷克女性人群中正确区分对照组和乳腺癌病例。基于配对数据,对照组的平均5年和终身乳腺癌风险分别为1.379±0.668和7.990±3.184,乳腺癌患者组分别为1.375±0.692和8.028±3.506。原始的盖尔模型也无法正确描述捷克人群中特定年龄的乳腺癌发病基线风险。作为回应,作者开发了两种修改/本地调整模型的变体。
原始的盖尔模型不是捷克女性人群准确的乳腺癌风险评估工具。