Forstmeier Wolfgang
University of Sheffield and Max Planck Institute for Ornithology, Department of Animal and Plant Sciences, Postfach 1564, 82305 Starnberg (Seewiesen), Germany.
Proc Biol Sci. 2005 Dec 22;272(1581):2641-9. doi: 10.1098/rspb.2005.3264.
A recent study on a captive zebra finch population suggested that variation in digit ratio (i.e. the relative length of the second to the fourth toe) might be an indicator of the action of sex steroids during embryo development, as is widely assumed for human digits. Zebra finch digit ratio was found to vary with offspring sex, laying order of eggs within a clutch, and to predict aspects of female mating behaviour. Hence, it was proposed that the measurement of digit ratio would give insights into how an individual's behaviour is shaped by its maternal environment. Studying 500 individuals of a different zebra finch population I set out to: (1) determine the proximate causes of variation in digit ratio by means of quantitative genetics and (2) to search for phenotypic and genetic correlations between digit ratio, sexual behaviour and aspects of fitness. In contrast to the earlier study, I found no sexual dimorphism in digit ratio and no effect of either laying order or experimentally altered hatching order on digit ratio. Instead, I found that variation in digit ratio was almost entirely additive genetic, with heritability estimates ranging from 71 to 84%. The rearing environment (from egg deposition to independence) explained an additional 5-6% of the variation in digit ratio, but there was no indication of any maternal effects transmitted through the egg. I found highly significant phenotypic correlations (and genetic correlations of similar size) between digit ratio and male song rate (positive correlation) as well as between digit ratio and female hopping activity in a choice chamber (negative correlation). Rather surprisingly, the strength of these correlations differed significantly between subsequent generations of the same population, illustrating how quickly such correlations can appear and disappear probably due to genotype-environment interactions.
最近一项针对圈养斑胸草雀种群的研究表明,指比(即第二趾与第四趾的相对长度)的变化可能是胚胎发育过程中性类固醇作用的一个指标,就像人们普遍认为人类手指的情况一样。研究发现,斑胸草雀的指比会因后代性别、一窝蛋中的产卵顺序而有所不同,并且能够预测雌性的交配行为。因此,有人提出,测量指比将有助于深入了解个体行为是如何由其母体环境塑造的。我对另一个斑胸草雀种群的500只个体进行了研究,旨在:(1)通过数量遗传学确定指比变化的直接原因,以及(2)寻找指比、性行为和适应性方面之间的表型和遗传相关性。与早期研究不同的是,我没有发现指比存在性别二态性,产卵顺序或实验改变的孵化顺序对指比也没有影响。相反,我发现指比的变化几乎完全是加性遗传的,遗传力估计值在71%至84%之间。饲养环境(从卵的沉积到独立)又解释了指比变化的5%至6%,但没有迹象表明存在通过卵传递的母体效应。我发现指比与雄性鸣唱率之间存在高度显著(且大小相似的遗传相关性)的表型相关性(正相关),以及指比与雌性在选择箱中的跳跃活动之间存在高度显著的表型相关性(负相关)。相当令人惊讶的是,这些相关性的强度在同一群体的后代之间存在显著差异,这说明了由于基因型 - 环境相互作用,此类相关性可能出现和消失得有多快。