Modestin J, Schwarzenbach F A, Würmle O
Psychiatric University Clinic, Bern, Switzerland.
Br J Med Psychol. 1992 Jun;65(2):147-56. doi: 10.1111/j.2044-8341.1992.tb01694.x.
We studied therapeutic factors influencing suicide during out-patient treatment in severely ill discharged psychiatric in-patients. A subsample of 25 suicide and 27 control patients were all treated by psychiatrists at the time of their suicide or at a corresponding point of time. We were not able to identify any significant psychosocial or clinical pre-discharge differences between the two groups. After discharge, the patients of the control group were treated by psychiatrists with substantially longer professional training-plus-experience, the therapist's experience being the most important therapy factor contributing to the different outcome. On the whole, the contribution of the therapy factors was modest, however, explaining only 26 per cent of the group variance.
我们研究了影响重症出院精神科住院患者门诊治疗期间自杀行为的治疗因素。选取了25名自杀患者和27名对照患者作为子样本,所有患者在自杀时或相应时间点均由精神科医生进行治疗。我们未能识别出两组患者在出院前的任何显著心理社会或临床差异。出院后,对照组患者由专业培训和经验更丰富的精神科医生治疗,治疗师的经验是导致不同结果的最重要治疗因素。然而,总体而言,治疗因素的作用不大,仅解释了26%的组内差异。