Ogawa Kiyohisa, Yoshida Atsushi, Inokuchi Wataru, Naniwa Toyohisa
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, School of Medicine, Keio University, Tokyo, Japan.
J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2005 Nov-Dec;14(6):591-8. doi: 10.1016/j.jse.2005.03.007.
This study's objective is to elucidate the relationship between acromial spur formation and rotator cuff pathology or aging. The subjects comprised 1029 shoulders in control, cadaveric, and operative groups. A radiograph in the supraspinatus outlet view was taken in all subjects. The lengths of the incident spurs were measured and classified into 3 sizes (small, <5 mm; medium, <10 mm; and large, > or =10 mm). The rotator cuff was macroscopically classified as normal or as having bursal-side fraying, joint-side tear, intratendinous tear, bursal-side tear, complete tear limited to the supraspinatus tendon, or massive tear. In the control group, the overall incidence of spurs and spur size increased with advancing age (P < .001), but the majority of spurs were small (<5 mm). In the cadaveric group, the overall incidence did not correlate with advancing age (P > .05). However, spur size increased with age in subjects aged 50 years or older (P < .001). The incidence of spurs in rotator cuffs with bursal-side tears was highest and was significantly higher than that in normal cuffs and cuffs with bursal-side fraying and intratendinous tears. We observed 40% of medium spurs and 69% of large spurs in cases with bursal-side tears, complete tears limited to the supraspinatus tendon, and massive tears. In the operative group, the overall incidence correlated to advancing age (P < .001), reaching 80% or more in subjects aged 30 years or older. In addition, the size of spurs was larger than that in the other 2 groups in all age groups with few exceptions (P < .05). Small spurs were associated with advancing age. Morphologic change to the bursal side of the rotator cuff may enhance spur growth. The presence of a small spur has no diagnostic value for rotator cuff tears. Spurs measuring 5 mm or more, however, are of diagnostic value because of their high rate of association with bursal-side tear, complete tears limited to the supraspinatus tendon, or massive tears.
本研究的目的是阐明肩峰骨刺形成与肩袖病变或衰老之间的关系。研究对象包括对照组、尸体组和手术组的1029个肩部。对所有研究对象均拍摄了冈上肌出口位X线片。测量出现的骨刺长度,并将其分为3种大小(小,<5mm;中,<10mm;大,≥10mm)。肩袖在宏观上分为正常或存在滑囊侧磨损、关节侧撕裂、肌腱内撕裂、滑囊侧撕裂、仅限于冈上肌腱的完全撕裂或巨大撕裂。在对照组中,骨刺的总体发生率和骨刺大小随年龄增长而增加(P<.001),但大多数骨刺较小(<5mm)。在尸体组中,总体发生率与年龄增长无关(P>.05)。然而,在50岁及以上的研究对象中,骨刺大小随年龄增长而增加(P<.001)。滑囊侧撕裂的肩袖中骨刺的发生率最高,且显著高于正常肩袖以及存在滑囊侧磨损和肌腱内撕裂的肩袖。在滑囊侧撕裂、仅限于冈上肌腱的完全撕裂和巨大撕裂的病例中,我们观察到40%的中号骨刺和69%的大号骨刺。在手术组中,总体发生率与年龄增长相关(P<.001),在30岁及以上的研究对象中达到80%或更高。此外,除少数例外情况外,所有年龄组的骨刺大小均大于其他两组(P<.05)。小骨刺与年龄增长相关。肩袖滑囊侧的形态改变可能会促进骨刺生长。小骨刺的存在对肩袖撕裂没有诊断价值。然而,长度为5mm或以上的骨刺具有诊断价值,因为它们与滑囊侧撕裂、仅限于冈上肌腱的完全撕裂或巨大撕裂的关联率很高。