Aarnoudse Wilbert, Geven Maartje, Barbato Emanuele, Botman Kees-joost, De Bruyne Bernard, Pijls Nico H J
Department of Cardiology, Catharina Hospital, Eindhoven, The Netherlands.
Am J Cardiol. 2005 Dec 15;96(12):1627-30. doi: 10.1016/j.amjcard.2005.07.078. Epub 2005 Oct 21.
For accurate measurement of the fractional flow reserve (FFR) of the myocardium, the presence of maximum hyperemia is of paramount importance. It has been suggested that the hyperemic effect of the conventionally used hyperemic stimulus, adenosine, could be submaximal in patients who have microvascular dysfunction and that adding alpha-blocking agents could augment the hyperemic response in these patients. We studied the effect of the nonselective alpha-blocking agent phentolamine, which was administered in addition to adenosine after achieving hyperemia, in patients who had microvascular disease and those who did not. Thirty patients who were referred for percutaneous coronary intervention were selected. Of these 30 patients, 15 had strong indications for microvascular disease and 15 did not. FFR was measured using intracoronary adenosine, intravenous adenosine, and intracoronary papaverine before and after intracoronary administration of the nonselective alpha blocker phentolamine. In patients who did not have microvascular disease, no differences in hyperemic response to adenosine were noted, whether or not alpha blockade was given before adenosine administration; FFR levels before and after phentolamine were 0.76 and 0.75, respectively, using intracoronary adenosine (p = 0.10) and 0.75 and 0.74, respectively, using intravenous adenosine (p = 0.20). In contrast, in patients who had microvascular disease, some increase in hyperemic response was observed after administration of phentolamine; FFR levels decreased from 0.74 to 0.70 using intracoronary adenosine (p = 0.003) and from 0.75 to 0.72 using intravenous adenosine (p = 0.04). Although statistically significant, the observed further decrease in microvascular resistance after addition of phentolamine was small and did not affect clinical decision making in any patient. In conclusion, when measuring FFR, routinely adding an alpha-blocking agent to adenosine does not affect clinical decision making.
为准确测量心肌血流储备分数(FFR),最大充血状态的存在至关重要。有人提出,传统使用的充血刺激剂腺苷对微血管功能障碍患者的充血作用可能未达最大,而添加α阻滞剂可增强这些患者的充血反应。我们研究了非选择性α阻滞剂酚妥拉明在充血后除腺苷外给药,对有微血管疾病和无微血管疾病患者的影响。选取了30例因经皮冠状动脉介入治疗而转诊的患者。在这30例患者中,15例有微血管疾病的强烈指征,15例没有。在冠状动脉内给予非选择性α阻滞剂酚妥拉明前后,分别使用冠状动脉内腺苷、静脉内腺苷和冠状动脉内罂粟碱测量FFR。在没有微血管疾病的患者中,无论在腺苷给药前是否给予α阻滞剂,对腺苷的充血反应均无差异;使用冠状动脉内腺苷时,酚妥拉明给药前后的FFR水平分别为0.76和0.75(p = 0.10),使用静脉内腺苷时分别为0.75和0.74(p = 0.20)。相比之下,在有微血管疾病的患者中,给予酚妥拉明后观察到充血反应有所增加;使用冠状动脉内腺苷时,FFR水平从0.74降至0.70(p = 0.003),使用静脉内腺苷时从0.75降至0.72(p = 0.04)。尽管具有统计学意义,但添加酚妥拉明后观察到的微血管阻力进一步降低幅度较小,且未影响任何患者的临床决策。总之,在测量FFR时,常规在腺苷中添加α阻滞剂不会影响临床决策。