Güdücü Funda, Caliyurt Okan, Vardar Erdal, Tuğlu Cengiz, Abay Ercan
Trakya U Tip Fak., Psikiyatri AD., Edirne.
Turk Psikiyatri Derg. 2005 Winter;16(4):245-51.
Bright light therapy is effective and well tolerated in seasonal affective disorder and some studies reported an antidepressant effect of bright light also in non-seasonal depression. On the other hand, total sleep deprivation leads to a rapid and marked improvement of mood in 60% of depressed patients. Combinations of antidepressant medication with those somatic therapies are generally indicated. The aim of this study was to compare the efficacy of the combination of sertraline and partial sleep deprivation or light therapy with sertraline monotherapy in the treatment of major depression.
Thirty-seven patients with major depressive disorder were randomly allocated into 3 treatment groups. Thirteen were treated with sertraline and late partial sleep deprivation, 13 with sertraline and bright light therapy and 11 sertraline monotherapy as a control group. Outcome measures included daily (first 15 days) and weekly Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression and biweekly Hamilton Anxiety Rating Scale.
Partial sleep deprivation group improved significantly and more rapidly. Accelerated treatment response was shown in sleep deprivation group that improvement was observed after the third day. Bright light and sleep deprivation combinations with sertraline were more effective than sertraline monotherapy for accompanied anxiety in depression.
Late partial sleep deprivation in combination with sertraline can accelerate and increase the treatment response in non-seasonal major depressive disorder.
强光疗法对季节性情感障碍有效且耐受性良好,一些研究报告称强光对非季节性抑郁症也有抗抑郁作用。另一方面,完全睡眠剥夺可使60%的抑郁症患者情绪迅速且显著改善。抗抑郁药物与这些躯体疗法联合应用通常是有必要的。本研究的目的是比较舍曲林与部分睡眠剥夺或光疗联合应用与舍曲林单药治疗重度抑郁症的疗效。
37例重度抑郁症患者被随机分为3个治疗组。13例接受舍曲林和晚期部分睡眠剥夺治疗,13例接受舍曲林和强光疗法治疗,11例接受舍曲林单药治疗作为对照组。疗效指标包括每日(前15天)和每周的汉密尔顿抑郁量表以及每两周一次的汉密尔顿焦虑量表。
部分睡眠剥夺组改善显著且更快。睡眠剥夺组显示出加速的治疗反应,在第三天后观察到改善。舍曲林与强光和睡眠剥夺联合应用对抑郁症伴发的焦虑比舍曲林单药治疗更有效。
晚期部分睡眠剥夺与舍曲林联合应用可加速并增强非季节性重度抑郁症的治疗反应。