Sayin Aslihan, Aslan Salçuk
Gazi U Tip Fak., Psikiyatri AD., Ankara.
Turk Psikiyatri Derg. 2005 Winter;16(4):276-83.
The terms temperament, character and personality have been used almost synonymously despite their different meanings. Hippocratic physicians conceptualized illness, including melancholia, in dimensional terms as an out-growth of premorbid characteristics. In modern times, full-scale application of this dimensional concept to psychiatric disorders led Kraepelin, Schneider and Kretschmer to hypothesize that the 'endogenous psychoses are nothing other than marked accentuation of normal types of temperament'. Akiskal's 'soft-bipolarity' and 'affective temperaments' concepts and Cloninger's psychobiological model of temperament and character, which includes four temperament and three character dimensions, are examples of this dimensional approach from the last two decades. Hypotheses concerning the relationship between personality disorders and mood disorders have been described, but it is likely that a single unitary model would not adequately capture the complexity inherent in the relationship between mood and personality disorders. The DSM multiaxial approach to diagnosis encourages the clinician to distinguish state (Axis I) from trait (Axis II) features of mental disorders. Categorical systems like DSM have been criticised because of their inability to mention temperament, character and personality features. In this review, examples of dimensional approaches to mood disorders are given and discussed under the influence of temperament, character and personality disorders. For this purpose, literature from 1980 to 2004 has been reviewed through Pub/med, using the following key words.
尽管气质、性格和人格这几个术语含义不同,但它们几乎一直被当作同义词使用。希波克拉底派医生将疾病(包括忧郁症)概念化为维度性的,认为是病前特征的一种延伸。在现代,将这一维度概念全面应用于精神障碍,使得克雷佩林、施奈德和克雷奇默提出假说,认为“内源性精神病无非是正常气质类型的显著强化”。阿基斯卡尔的“软双相性”和“情感气质”概念,以及克隆宁格的气质和性格心理生物学模型(包括四个气质维度和三个性格维度),都是过去二十年这种维度方法的实例。关于人格障碍与心境障碍之间关系的假说已有描述,但单一的统一模型可能无法充分涵盖心境障碍与人格障碍关系中固有的复杂性。《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》(DSM)的多轴诊断方法鼓励临床医生区分精神障碍的状态特征(轴I)和特质特征(轴II)。像DSM这样的分类系统受到了批评,因为它们无法提及气质、性格和人格特征。在本综述中,给出并讨论了在气质、性格和人格障碍影响下对心境障碍的维度方法实例。为此,通过Pub/med对1980年至2004年的文献进行了综述,使用了以下关键词。