Myers Stephen A, Bennett Timothy L
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Kansas Medical Center, Kansas City 66160-7316, USA.
J Reprod Med. 2005 Sep;50(9):659-62.
To examine the effect of peritoneal closure at prior cesarean section on the occurrence of abdomino-pelvic adhesions at subsequent cesarean section.
An observational chart review study was performed involving 191 cases of repeat cesarean section occurring from January 2001 through July 30, 2002. An adhesion score was created according to the following: a grade 1 score was assigned when no adhesions were present, a grade 2 when adhesions were present but no surgery required, a grade 3 when adhesiolysis was required and there was inability to exteriorize the uterus, and a grade 4 when adhesiolysis was required prior to delivery. Scores were assigned and tabulated as a result of the review of the operative records of 191 cases. When available, the operative record of prior cesarean section was examined to determine if visceral and parietal peritoneal closure had been performed at the prior operation.
During the year and a half for which data were examined, significant abdominopelvic adhesions (grades 3 and 4) were encountered 21% of the time (40 of 191) at repeat cesarean section. Prior peritoneal closure resulted in significant adhesions in 1 of 18 patients compared to 17 of 40 patients when no prior peritoneal closure was recorded (Fisher's exact probability = 0.003).
While preliminary, in the absence of any substantive benefit or published data regarding adhesionformation in cesarean section that contradict this finding, the practice of nonclosure of visceral and parietal peritoneum at cesarean section should be questioned.
探讨首次剖宫产时腹膜关闭对再次剖宫产时腹盆腔粘连发生情况的影响。
进行了一项观察性图表回顾研究,纳入2001年1月至2002年7月30日期间发生的191例再次剖宫产病例。根据以下情况创建粘连评分:无粘连时给予1级评分;有粘连但无需手术时给予2级评分;需要粘连松解且无法娩出子宫时给予3级评分;分娩前需要粘连松解时给予4级评分。通过回顾191例病例的手术记录进行评分并列表。如有可能,检查首次剖宫产的手术记录,以确定上次手术时是否进行了脏腹膜和壁腹膜关闭。
在检查数据的一年半时间里,再次剖宫产时21%(191例中的40例)出现了严重的腹盆腔粘连(3级和4级)。首次剖宫产时进行了腹膜关闭的18例患者中有1例出现了严重粘连,而未记录首次剖宫产腹膜关闭的40例患者中有17例出现了严重粘连(Fisher精确概率 = 0.003)。
虽然是初步研究,但在没有任何实质性益处或已发表的关于剖宫产粘连形成的与该发现相矛盾的数据的情况下,剖宫产时不关闭脏腹膜和壁腹膜的做法值得质疑。