Vestewig R E, Moss M K
Department of Psychology, Wright State University, Dayton, Ohio 45435, USA.
J Pers Assess. 1977 Dec;41(6):589-90. doi: 10.1207/s15327752jpa4106_2.
Crumbaugh (1977) reexamines an earlier study showing no validity for graphoanalysis (Vestewig, Santee, & Moss, 1976), and from considerations of the methodology and from reanalysis of the data findings some validity for the system. This rejoinder points out conceptual and statistical errors in his reply, and reaffirms the conclusion of the earlier study.
克伦baugh(1977年)重新审视了一项早期研究,该研究表明笔迹分析无效(韦斯特维格、桑蒂和莫斯,1976年),并从方法论的角度以及对数据的重新分析中发现该系统具有一定的有效性。这一回应指出了他回复中的概念性和统计性错误,并重申了早期研究的结论。