Smith Timothy L, Mendolia-Loffredo Sabrina, Loehrl Todd A, Sparapani Rodney, Laud Purushottam W, Nattinger Ann B
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Oregon Health and Science University, Portland, Oregon 97201, USA.
Laryngoscope. 2005 Dec;115(12):2199-205. doi: 10.1097/01.mlg.0000182825.82910.80.
To assess objective and quality of life (QOL) outcomes before and after endoscopic sinus surgery (ESS) in patients with chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) and to determine preoperative factors that predict surgical outcome in these patients.
One hundred nineteen adult patients with CRS and a mean follow-up of 1.4 +/- 0.35 years were evaluated prospectively including the following patient factors: prior sinus surgery, polyps, asthma, acetylsalicylic acid intolerance (ASA), smoking, allergy, depression, and sex. Computed tomography (CT), endoscopy, and QOL assessment was performed. Predictive value of patient factors was determined based on change in endoscopy and QOL scores after ESS.
Objective outcomes: preoperative CT scores were significantly worse in patients with polyps, asthma, and ASA, whereas CT score was unaffected by prior sinus surgery, smoking, allergy, depression, and sex. Patients with CRS demonstrated significant improvement on nasal endoscopy after ESS, but preoperative, postoperative, and change in scores were affected by certain patient factors. Endoscopy scores were significantly worse in patients with prior sinus surgery, polyps, asthma, and ASA, but these patients also experienced the greatest improvement in endoscopy scores. Smokers and patients with depression had the least change in endoscopy scores. QOL outcomes: patients with CRS experienced improvement in QOL after ESS. Pre- and postoperative QOL was positively affected by polyps and adversely affected by ASA, depression, and female sex, but these groups still experienced significant improvement in QOL scores. Pre- and postoperative QOL was unaffected by prior sinus surgery, asthma, smoking, and allergies, and all of these groups experienced significant improvement in QOL scores. Factors predictive of outcome: ASA and depression were predictive of worse outcome. Preoperative CT scores approached significance as being predictive of outcome.
Surgical management of CRS was associated with significant improvement on objective and QOL measures; however, specific patient factors, in particular ASA and depression, predict poorer outcome. Preoperative CT may be a predictor of endoscopic and QOL outcome and deserves further study.
评估慢性鼻-鼻窦炎(CRS)患者内镜鼻窦手术(ESS)前后的客观指标及生活质量(QOL)结果,并确定预测这些患者手术结局的术前因素。
对119例成年CRS患者进行前瞻性评估,平均随访1.4±0.35年,评估以下患者因素:既往鼻窦手术史、息肉、哮喘、阿司匹林不耐受(ASA)、吸烟、过敏、抑郁和性别。进行了计算机断层扫描(CT)、内镜检查和QOL评估。根据ESS后内镜检查和QOL评分的变化确定患者因素的预测价值。
客观结果:息肉、哮喘和ASA患者的术前CT评分明显更差,而CT评分不受既往鼻窦手术、吸烟、过敏、抑郁和性别的影响。CRS患者在ESS后鼻内镜检查有显著改善,但术前、术后及评分变化受某些患者因素影响。既往有鼻窦手术、息肉、哮喘和ASA的患者内镜检查评分明显更差,但这些患者内镜检查评分的改善也最大。吸烟者和抑郁患者的内镜检查评分变化最小。QOL结果:CRS患者在ESS后QOL有所改善。术前和术后QOL受息肉的积极影响,受ASA、抑郁和女性性别的不利影响,但这些组的QOL评分仍有显著改善。术前和术后QOL不受既往鼻窦手术、哮喘、吸烟和过敏的影响,所有这些组的QOL评分都有显著改善。结局预测因素:ASA和抑郁预示结局较差。术前CT评分接近具有结局预测意义。
CRS的手术治疗与客观指标和QOL指标的显著改善相关;然而,特定的患者因素,特别是ASA和抑郁预示着较差的结局。术前CT可能是内镜和QOL结局的预测指标,值得进一步研究。