Conesa C, Ríos A, Ramírez P, Sánchez J, Sánchez E, Rodríguez M M, Martínez L, Ramos F, Parrilla P
Coordinación Regional de Trasplantes de la Comunidad Autónoma de Murcia, Consejería de Sanidad, Spain.
Transplant Proc. 2005 Nov;37(9):3631-5. doi: 10.1016/j.transproceed.2005.10.036.
Living liver donation is not exempt from risks to the donor, although it is currently ethically accepted. It is important to examine the level of acceptance among the different health levels toward this therapeutic option, in order to design promotion and awareness-raising activities. The objective herein was to analyze the attitudes and the factors that condition them among nursing personnel in Primary Care (PC) toward living liver donation.
This random survey was stratified by geographical location (6 health areas in our community) among PC nurses, obtaining a total of 139 nurses from 34 health centers. Attitudes toward living liver donation were evaluated using a questionnaire on donation which included different psychosocial variables. For the distribution of the questionnaire, the nursing coordinator of each centers was contacted to distribute questionnaires which were completed anonymously. The chi-square test and Student t test were applied.
Attitudes toward living liver donation were favorable in 89% of those questioned (n = 124) if it is related donation; 3% (n = 4) were against donating a living hemiliver and 8% (n = 11) had doubts. It is important that up to 76% (n = 106) have cared for transplant patients or patients awaiting transplant, however, no relationship was observed with attitude to this type of donation (P = .489). Of all the analyzed variables, there was only a significant relationship between attitudes and concern about possible body mutilation (P < .0005), and partners attitudes toward this matter (P < .0005). It is noteworthy that no relationship was found with attitudes toward cadaveric donation (P = .062).
Despite the risk of morbidity and mortality in the donor, the attitude of the PC nursing personnel toward living liver donation was favorable, especially if the donation is related.
尽管活体肝捐赠目前在伦理上已被接受,但捐赠者仍需承担风险。为了设计推广和提高认识的活动,研究不同健康水平人群对这种治疗选择的接受程度非常重要。本文的目的是分析基层医疗护理人员对活体肝捐赠的态度及其影响因素。
本次随机调查按地理位置(我们社区的6个健康区域)对基层医疗护士进行分层,从34个健康中心共获得139名护士。使用一份关于捐赠的问卷评估对活体肝捐赠的态度,问卷包括不同的社会心理变量。为了发放问卷,联系了每个中心的护理协调员以发放问卷,问卷采用匿名方式填写。应用卡方检验和学生t检验。
如果是亲属捐赠,89%(n = 124)的被调查者对活体肝捐赠持赞成态度;3%(n = 4)反对捐赠半肝,8%(n = 11)表示怀疑。重要的是,高达76%(n = 106)的人曾护理过移植患者或等待移植的患者,然而,未观察到与对这种捐赠类型的态度之间存在关联(P = 0.489)。在所有分析的变量中,态度与对可能的身体残缺的担忧(P < 0.0005)以及伴侣对此事的态度(P <
0.0005)之间仅存在显著关联。值得注意的是,未发现与对尸体捐赠的态度之间存在关联(P = 0.062)。
尽管捐赠者存在发病和死亡风险,但基层医疗护理人员对活体肝捐赠的态度是积极的,特别是在亲属捐赠的情况下。