Zakerinia M, Khojasteh H N, Ramzi M, Haghshenas M
Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Namazee Hospital, Shiraz, Iran.
Transplant Proc. 2005 Dec;37(10):4477-81. doi: 10.1016/j.transproceed.2005.10.014.
Allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT) was performed on 113 Iranian transfusion-dependent thalassemia major patients from May 1993 through September 2003. To have at least 2 years follow-up, we report BMT on 90 patients transplanted up to December 2001. The donors were human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-identical, mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC)-nonreactive siblings (n = 74) on parents (n = 6); HLA-identical MLC-reactive siblings (n = 5) or parents (n = 1); and one HLA antigen-mismatched sibling (n = 4). The induction regimen in 11 patients was oral busulfan (BU) (14 mg/kg) and IV cyclophosphamide (CY; 200 mg/kg); in fifteen patients it was BU (15 mg/kg) and cyclophosphamide (CY; 200 mg/kg); in 47 patients, BU (15 mg/kg), CY (200 mg/kg), and short course of anti-thymocyte globulin (ATG, horse; 40 mg/kg including 10 mg/kg on days -2, -1, +1, +2); and in 15 patients, BU (15 mg/kg) CY (200 mg/kg), and ATG (60 to 100 mg/kg; 10 mg/kg at 3 to 5 days before and after BMT). Graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) prophylaxis consisted of cyclosporine and prednisolone. The group who received BU (14 mg/kg) and CY (200 mg/kg), as compared to the group receiving BU (15 mg/kg) and CY (200 mg/kg), was of younger age and lower risk; median age 7 versus 10 years, and 46% versus 7% in Lucarelli's risk group class I (the best prognostic group), respectively. These patients showed a lower disease-free survival (DFS), namely 64% versus 73%, with a follow up of 2 to 10.5 years. Thus from 9.5 years ago, our standard protocol for BU has been 15 mg/kg. The group who received "short" ATG (40 mg/kg), BU (15 mg/kg), and CY (200 mg/kg) showed almost the same outcome as the group who received a higher dose of ATG (60 to 100 mg/kg), namely DFS 72% versus 73%, respectively, despite the fact that half of both groups were included in the Lucarelli's risk group class III (the worst prognostic group) 49% versus 53%. We showed the same DFS for the patients who received BU (15 mg/kg), CY (200 mg/kg), and no ATG compared with the ATG group (73% vs 72%), but 27% of the group without ATG developed grade IV acute GVHD and 54% developed chronic GVHD. In the group with short ATG, 15% and 17% of patients developed grade IV acute and chronic GVHD, respectively. There was no significant difference for falls in platelets and white blood cell or engraftment days and the number of packed red blood cell transfusions among the groups. The median hospital stay was longer for the group with BU (15 mg/kg), CY (200 mg/kg) namely 81 versus 61 to 65 days. Second bone marrow infusions were needed in 6% and 20% of patients who received ATG doses of (40 versus 60 to 100 mg/kg; respectively (1 to 2 month post-BMT). BU at a dose of 15 mg/kg was more effective than 14 mg/kg BU for its myeloablative properties. By adding "short" ATG course to the conditioning regimen, the incidence of grade IV acute and chronic GVHD was reduced in thalassemic patients, especially when an HLA disparity was present.
1993年5月至2003年9月,对113例伊朗重型输血依赖型地中海贫血患者进行了异基因骨髓移植(BMT)。为了至少有2年的随访,我们报告了截至2001年12月接受BMT的90例患者的情况。供者为人类白细胞抗原(HLA)相合、混合淋巴细胞培养(MLC)无反应的同胞(n = 74)、父母(n = 6);HLA相合、MLC有反应的同胞(n = 5)或父母(n = 1);以及1例HLA抗原不相合的同胞(n = 4)。11例患者的诱导方案为口服白消安(BU)(14 mg/kg)和静脉注射环磷酰胺(CY;200 mg/kg);15例患者为BU(15 mg/kg)和环磷酰胺(CY;200 mg/kg);47例患者为BU(15 mg/kg)、CY(200 mg/kg)和短疗程抗胸腺细胞球蛋白(ATG,马;40 mg/kg,包括在-2、-1、+1、+2天各10 mg/kg);15例患者为BU(15 mg/kg)、CY(200 mg/kg)和ATG(60至100 mg/kg;在BMT前后3至5天各10 mg/kg)。移植物抗宿主病(GVHD)预防方案包括环孢素和泼尼松龙。接受BU(14 mg/kg)和CY(200 mg/kg)的组与接受BU(15 mg/kg)和CY(200 mg/kg)的组相比,年龄更小、风险更低;中位年龄分别为7岁和10岁,在卢卡雷利风险组I级(预后最佳组)中的比例分别为46%和7%。这些患者的无病生存率(DFS)较低,分别为64%和73%,随访时间为2至10.5年。因此,从9.5年前起,我们的BU标准方案为15 mg/kg。接受“短疗程”ATG(40 mg/kg)、BU(15 mg/kg)和CY(200 mg/kg)的组与接受更高剂量ATG(60至100 mg/kg)的组结果几乎相同,DFS分别为72%和73%,尽管两组中各有一半患者属于卢卡雷利风险组III级(预后最差组),比例分别为49%和53%。我们发现接受BU(15 mg/kg)、CY(200 mg/kg)且未使用ATG的患者与使用ATG的患者DFS相同(73%对72%),但未使用ATG组中有27%的患者发生IV级急性GVHD,54%的患者发生慢性GVHD。在短疗程ATG组中,分别有15%和17%的患者发生IV级急性和慢性GVHD。各组之间血小板和白细胞减少情况、植入天数以及红细胞输注量均无显著差异。接受BU(15 mg/kg)、CY(200 mg/kg)组的中位住院时间更长,分别为81天和61至65天。接受ATG剂量为40 mg/kg和60至100 mg/kg的患者中,分别有6%和20%需要进行第二次骨髓输注(BMT后1至2个月)。15 mg/kg的BU因其清髓特性比14 mg/kg的BU更有效。通过在预处理方案中加入“短疗程”ATG,地中海贫血患者IV级急性和慢性GVHD的发生率降低,尤其是在存在HLA不相合的情况下。