Cekirge H Saruhan, Saatci Isil, Ozturk M Halil, Cil Barbaros, Arat Anil, Mawad Michel, Ergungor Fikret, Belen Deniz, Er Uygur, Turk Sami, Bavbek Murat, Sekerci Zeki, Beskonakli Ethem, Ozcan Osman E, Ozgen Tuncalp
Department of Radiology, Hacettepe University Hospital, Sihhiye, 06100, Ankara, Turkey.
Neuroradiology. 2006 Feb;48(2):113-26. doi: 10.1007/s00234-005-0007-6. Epub 2006 Jan 4.
We present the long-term clinical and angiographic follow-up results of 100 consecutive intracranial aneurysms treated with Onyx liquid embolic system (MTI, Irvine, Calif.), either alone or combined with an adjunctive stent, in a single center. A total of 100 aneurysms in 94 patients were treated with endosaccular Onyx packing. Intracranial stenting was used adjunctively in 25 aneurysms including 19 during initial treatment and 6 during retreatment. All aneurysms except two were located in the internal carotid artery. Of the 100 aneurysms, 35 were giant or large/wide-necked, and 65 were small. Follow-up angiography was performed in all 91 surviving patients (96 aneurysms) at 3 and/or 6 months. Follow-up angiography was performed at 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 years in 90, 41, 26, 6 and 2 patients, respectively. Overall, aneurysm recanalization was observed in 12 of 96 aneurysms with follow-up angiography (12.5%). All 12 were large or giant aneurysms, resulting in a 36% recanalization rate in the large and giant aneurysm group. One aneurysm out of 25 treated with the combination of a stent and Onyx showed recanalization. There was also no recanalization in the follow-up of small internal carotid artery aneurysms treated with balloon assistance only. At final follow-up, procedure- or device-related permanent neurological morbidity was present in eight patients (8.3%). There were two procedure-related and one disease-related (subarachnoid hemorrhage) deaths (mortality 3.2%). Delayed spontaneous asymptomatic occlusion of the parent vessel occurred in two patients, detected on routine follow-up. Onyx provides durable aneurysm occlusion with parent artery reconstruction resulting in perfectly stable 1-year to 5-year follow-up angiography both in small aneurysms treated with balloon assistance only (0% recanalization rate) and large or giant aneurysms treated with stent and Onyx combination (4% recanalization rate). Endosaccular Onyx packing with balloon assistance may not be adequate for stable long-term results in those with a large or giant aneurysm. However, the recanalization rate of 36% in these aneurysms is better than the reported results with other techniques, i.e., coils with or without adjunctive bare stents.
我们展示了在单一中心对连续100例颅内动脉瘤使用奥尼克斯液体栓塞系统(MTI,加利福尼亚州欧文市)单独或联合辅助支架治疗后的长期临床和血管造影随访结果。94例患者共100个动脉瘤接受了囊内奥尼克斯填充治疗。25个动脉瘤在治疗过程中使用了颅内支架辅助,其中19个在初始治疗时使用,6个在再次治疗时使用。除2个动脉瘤外,所有动脉瘤均位于颈内动脉。100个动脉瘤中,35个为巨大或大/宽颈动脉瘤,65个为小动脉瘤。91例存活患者(96个动脉瘤)在3个月和/或6个月时进行了随访血管造影。分别有90例、41例、26例、6例和2例患者在1年、2年、3年、4年和5年时进行了随访血管造影。总体而言,96个接受随访血管造影的动脉瘤中有12个出现再通(12.5%)。所有12个均为大或巨大动脉瘤,大/巨大动脉瘤组的再通率为36%。在25个接受支架和奥尼克斯联合治疗的动脉瘤中,有1个出现再通。仅采用球囊辅助治疗小颈内动脉瘤的随访中也未出现再通。在最终随访时,8例患者(8.3%)出现了与手术或器械相关的永久性神经功能障碍。有2例与手术相关的死亡和1例与疾病相关(蛛网膜下腔出血)的死亡(死亡率3.2%)。在常规随访中发现2例患者出现了延迟性自发性无症状的载瘤动脉闭塞。奥尼克斯能提供持久的动脉瘤闭塞并重建载瘤动脉,对于仅采用球囊辅助治疗的小动脉瘤(再通率0%)以及采用支架和奥尼克斯联合治疗的大或巨大动脉瘤(再通率4%),可在1年至5年的随访血管造影中获得完美稳定的结果。对于大或巨大动脉瘤患者,仅采用球囊辅助的囊内奥尼克斯填充可能无法获得稳定的长期效果。然而,这些动脉瘤36%的再通率优于其他技术(即带或不带辅助裸支架的弹簧圈)所报道的结果。