Gallagher Peter, Leitch Melville M, Massey Anna E, McAllister-Williams R Hamish, Young Allan H
School of Neurology, Neurobiology and Psychiatry, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
J Psychopharmacol. 2006 Sep;20(5):643-9. doi: 10.1177/0269881106060585. Epub 2006 Jan 9.
An increasing number of studies are utilizing saliva sampling as a method of assessing adrenal steroid secretion. Saliva samples have certain advantages over plasma, being non-invasive and easily collected. However, some methods of collection may compromise the accuracy of the assay, particularly those which employ aids to stimulate saliva production. We sought to compare the accuracy of cortisol and dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) measurement by examining the association between plasma levels, saliva and saliva collected using a citric acid-treated salivette device. Twenty six healthy male volunteers were recruited for the study. To increase the range of steroid levels in the samples collected, half the subjects were pre-treated with hydrocortisone (20mg, twice a day for 7 days) and half with placebo. Saliva samples were then collected from each subject using both a 'passive drool' method and a citric acid-treated salivette. A plasma sample was also collected. Cortisol and DHEA levels were measured by radioimmunoassay. For cortisol levels, both methods of saliva collection correlated highly with plasma levels and with each other (r 0.85; R(2) 0.72 for all). For DHEA levels, only saliva samples collected using the unstimulated collection method correlated with plasma levels. DHEA collected using the salivette device did not correlate significantly with either plasma or the unstimulated saliva (r 0.2;R(2) 0.04). It is crucial that future studies are aware of these issues and are cognizant of the effects of the method of collection when examining steroid levels in saliva.
越来越多的研究将唾液采样作为评估肾上腺类固醇分泌的一种方法。与血浆相比,唾液样本具有某些优势,即非侵入性且易于采集。然而,一些采集方法可能会影响检测的准确性,尤其是那些借助辅助手段刺激唾液分泌的方法。我们试图通过研究血浆水平、唾液以及使用柠檬酸处理过的唾液采集装置收集的唾液之间的关联,来比较皮质醇和脱氢表雄酮(DHEA)测量的准确性。招募了26名健康男性志愿者参与该研究。为了扩大所采集样本中类固醇水平的范围,一半受试者接受氢化可的松预处理(20mg,每天两次,共7天),另一半接受安慰剂预处理。然后使用“被动流涎”法和柠檬酸处理过的唾液采集装置从每个受试者收集唾液样本。还采集了一份血浆样本。通过放射免疫分析法测量皮质醇和DHEA水平。对于皮质醇水平,两种唾液采集方法与血浆水平以及彼此之间都高度相关(所有相关性r均为0.85;R²均为0.72)。对于DHEA水平,只有使用未刺激采集方法收集的唾液样本与血浆水平相关。使用唾液采集装置收集的DHEA与血浆或未刺激唾液均无显著相关性(r为0.2;R²为0.04)。至关重要的是,未来的研究要意识到这些问题,并在检测唾液中的类固醇水平时认识到采集方法的影响。