Tang Z Y, Zhou H Y, Zhao G, Chai L M, Zhou M, Lu J Z, Liu K D, Havas H F, Nauts H C
Liver Cancer Institute, Zhong Shan Hospital, Shanghai Medical University, Peoples Republic of China.
Med Oncol Tumor Pharmacother. 1991;8(1):23-8. doi: 10.1007/BF02988567.
Mixed bacterial vaccine (MBV) was employed in the multi-modality treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) during 1985-1988. Thirty eight patients undergoing palliative resection and cisplatin therapy (Series 1) and 48 patients with unresectable HCC who received hepatic artery ligation + intraarterial cisplatin infusion + radiotherapy (Series 2) were randomized to receive MBV or not. In series 1, the 1- and 2-year survival rates of MBV group and control were 75% vs 58% (P = 0.19) and 45% vs 39% (P = 0.23). In series 2, the 1-, 2- and 3-year survival rates were 59%, 41% and 41% for MBV group and 39%, 25% and 20% for the control, respectively (P1 = 0.07, P2 = 0.09, P3 = 0.07). In addition, MBV improved the "second look" resection rate to 40% as compared to 17% in the control (P greater than 0.05). MBV could also prevent such immunosuppression as decrease of macrophage activity caused by radiotherapy. We consider MBV a potential nonspecific immunostimulant in the multimodality treatment of HCC.
1985年至1988年期间,混合细菌疫苗(MBV)被用于肝细胞癌(HCC)的多模式治疗。38例接受姑息性切除和顺铂治疗的患者(系列1)以及48例无法切除的HCC患者,他们接受了肝动脉结扎+动脉内顺铂输注+放疗(系列2),被随机分组以决定是否接受MBV治疗。在系列1中,MBV组和对照组的1年和2年生存率分别为75%对58%(P = 0.19)和45%对39%(P = 0.23)。在系列2中,MBV组的1年、2年和3年生存率分别为59%、41%和41%,而对照组分别为39%、25%和20%(P1 = 0.07,P2 = 0.09,P3 = 0.07)。此外,与对照组的17%相比,MBV将“二次探查”切除率提高到了40%(P大于0.05)。MBV还可以预防放疗引起的巨噬细胞活性降低等免疫抑制。我们认为MBV是HCC多模式治疗中一种潜在的非特异性免疫刺激剂。