Donadio Carlo, Consani Cristina, Ardini Michela, Caprio Francesca, Grassi Giulia, Lucchesi Annalisa
Unită di Nefrologia, Dipartimento di Medicina Interna, Universită di Pisa, I-56100 Pisa, Italy.
Curr Drug Discov Technol. 2004 Oct;1(3):221-8. doi: 10.2174/1570163043334956.
The gold standards for the measurement of glomerular filtration rate (GFR) are inulin clearance and radioisotopic methods. However, creatinine clearance is the most used test to evaluate GFR in clinical practice. Its adequacy is questionable, since its repeatability is quite poor, mainly due to errors in the collection of urine. The aim of this study was to evaluate a new method to predict GFR from the body cell mass (BCM) and plasma creatinine (Pcr), avoiding urine collection. The values of BCM were obtained in 275 adult renal patients with different renal function, ranging from normality to advanced renal failure. The relationship of GFR (clearance of (99m)Tc-DTPA) with BCM and Pcr was calculated in the first 85 patients. A highly significant linear correlation was found between GFR and the ratio BCM/Pcr. Thereafter, GFR was predicted from BCM and Pcr (BCM GFR) with formulas derived from the relationships found between GFR and the ratio BCM/Pcr. For comparison, GFR was predicted also according to other prediction formulas: Cockcroft and Gault (CG GFR), and the simplified MDRD formula (MDRD GFR). BCM GFR gave a more precise estimate of GFR than CG GFR and MDRD GFR. In fact, BCM GFR had the best correlation and agreement with true GFR ((99m)Tc-DTPA). Furthermore, CG GFR and MDRD GFR markedly overestimated true GFR. Finally, the error of prediction of BCM GFR was definitely lower than that of the two other estimates of GFR. GFR can be predicted from BCM and plasma creatinine. This method, which is very simple and accurate, seems suitable to establish the adequate dosage of drugs cleared by the kidneys.
肾小球滤过率(GFR)测量的金标准是菊粉清除率和放射性同位素方法。然而,肌酐清除率是临床实践中评估GFR最常用的检测方法。其适用性存在疑问,因为其重复性相当差,主要是由于尿液收集存在误差。本研究的目的是评估一种从身体细胞质量(BCM)和血浆肌酐(Pcr)预测GFR的新方法,避免尿液收集。在275例不同肾功能的成年肾病患者中获得了BCM值,这些患者的肾功能从正常到晚期肾衰竭不等。在前85例患者中计算了GFR((99m)Tc - DTPA清除率)与BCM和Pcr的关系。发现GFR与BCM/Pcr比值之间存在高度显著的线性相关性。此后,使用从GFR与BCM/Pcr比值之间的关系推导得出的公式,从BCM和Pcr预测GFR(BCM GFR)。为了进行比较,还根据其他预测公式预测GFR:Cockcroft和Gault公式(CG GFR)以及简化的MDRD公式(MDRD GFR)。与CG GFR和MDRD GFR相比,BCM GFR对GFR的估计更精确。事实上,BCM GFR与真实GFR((99m)Tc - DTPA)具有最佳的相关性和一致性。此外,CG GFR和MDRD GFR明显高估了真实GFR。最后,BCM GFR的预测误差肯定低于GFR的其他两种估计方法。GFR可以从BCM和血浆肌酐预测。这种方法非常简单且准确,似乎适合确定经肾脏清除药物的合适剂量。