Bellagamba Francesca, Camaioni Luigia, Colonnesi Cristina
Department of Developmental and Social Psychology, University of Rome 'La Sapienza', Italy.
Dev Sci. 2006 Mar;9(2):182-8. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-7687.2006.00478.x.
The study investigated children's intention understanding using a longitudinal design. Thirty-two Italian children were tested on the 'Demonstration of Intention' in the Re-enactment paradigm devised by Meltzoff (1995a), at two ages. Mean age was 12 months at the first session and 15 months at the second session. Previous research by Meltzoff showed that 18-month-olds are able to re-enact what the adult intended to do, when an adult tried but failed to perform certain target acts. Bellagamba and Tomasello (1999) found that, compared to 18-month-olds, 12-month-olds are less able to imitate unsuccessful goal-directed actions. The current study had two main goals. The first was to replicate earlier findings on intention understanding in 12- and 15-month-olds longitudinally assessed. The second goal was to analyse which actions children perform when not producing the target act. A coding scheme was devised to evaluate these non-target actions. Results confirmed previous findings, i.e. children's tendency to produce the target act was higher at an older age. At a younger age the most frequent response was 'undifferentiated manipulation' of target objects, followed by 'approximation to the target action'. Since children differed in their intention understanding performance at the first session, we decided to check whether these individual differences remained stable at the second session. Individual children with high intention understanding performance at 12 months tended to remain high at 15 months of age.
该研究采用纵向设计调查儿童的意图理解能力。32名意大利儿童在梅尔佐夫(1995a)设计的重演范式中的“意图示范”测试中,接受了两个年龄段的测试。第一次测试时的平均年龄为12个月,第二次测试时为15个月。梅尔佐夫之前的研究表明,当成年人尝试但未能完成某些目标行为时,18个月大的儿童能够重演成年人原本打算做的事情。贝拉甘巴和托马塞洛(1999)发现,与18个月大的儿童相比,12个月大的儿童较难模仿未成功的目标导向行为。本研究有两个主要目标。第一个目标是纵向评估12个月和15个月大儿童的意图理解能力,以复制早期的研究结果。第二个目标是分析儿童在未做出目标行为时会执行哪些动作。设计了一种编码方案来评估这些非目标行为。结果证实了之前的研究结果,即儿童做出目标行为的倾向在年龄较大时更高。在年龄较小时,最常见的反应是对目标物体进行“无差别操作”,其次是“接近目标动作”。由于儿童在第一次测试时的意图理解表现存在差异,我们决定检查这些个体差异在第二次测试时是否保持稳定。在12个月时意图理解表现较高的个体儿童在15个月时往往仍保持较高水平。