Krautgartner Monika, Alexandrowicz Rainer, Benda Norbert, Wancata Johannes
Dept. of Psychiatry, Medical University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria.
Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 2006 Apr;41(4):294-301. doi: 10.1007/s00127-005-0025-z. Epub 2006 Feb 14.
The aim of the present study was to estimate the need for psychiatric consultation services and psychiatric inpatient referral among inpatients of non-psychiatric hospital departments, and to assess the actual utilization of these services.
The study was carried out among 728 inpatients of physical rehabilitation wards, medical, surgical, and gynecological wards in Austrian hospitals. Psychiatric case identification was performed by research psychiatrists using the Clinical Interview Schedule (CIS). Diagnoses were given according to DSM-III-R. The assessment of need for consultation and inpatient referral was based on the clinical judgments of research psychiatrists.
Overall, 34.2% of the inpatients were cases according to the CIS-criteria, 51.8% of them needing either psychiatric consultation or inpatient referral according to research psychiatrists. In 66.7% of those for whom research psychiatrists had stated a need, this need was not met ("unmet need"), while only 33.3% of them had their need met. In contrast, a psychiatric consultation was performed among 5% of those patients not needing psychiatric services according to the research psychiatrists ("overprovision"). Variables of the health care system (i.e. department type and catchment area of the hospital) were among the predictors for "met needs".
The rate of actual psychiatric consultations and admissions to psychiatric wards was markedly lower than the need according to research psychiatrists' judgment.
本研究旨在评估非精神科医院科室住院患者对精神科会诊服务及精神科住院转诊的需求,并评估这些服务的实际利用情况。
该研究在奥地利医院的728名物理康复病房、内科、外科及妇科病房的住院患者中开展。研究精神科医生使用临床访谈问卷(CIS)进行精神科病例识别。诊断依据《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第三版修订本(DSM-III-R)给出。对会诊及住院转诊需求的评估基于研究精神科医生的临床判断。
总体而言,根据CIS标准,34.2%的住院患者为病例,其中51.8%的患者根据研究精神科医生的判断需要精神科会诊或住院转诊。在研究精神科医生表示有需求的患者中,66.7%的需求未得到满足(“未满足需求”),而只有33.3%的患者需求得到满足。相比之下,在研究精神科医生认为不需要精神科服务的患者中,有5%的患者接受了精神科会诊(“过度供给”)。医疗保健系统的变量(即科室类型和医院的服务区域)是“需求得到满足”的预测因素之一。
根据研究精神科医生的判断,实际精神科会诊及精神科病房收治率明显低于需求率。