Gonzalez Claudia L R, Ganel Tzvi, Goodale Melvyn A
Canadian Institutes of Health Research Group on Action and Perception, Department of Psychology, University of Western Ontario, London N6A 5C2, Canada.
J Neurophysiol. 2006 Jun;95(6):3496-501. doi: 10.1152/jn.01187.2005. Epub 2006 Feb 22.
The idea that visually guided action is independent of visual perception has been supported by neurological, neuropsychological, and behavioral studies. In healthy subjects, evidence for this distinction has come from psychophysical studies of the effects of visual illusions on perceptual judgments and object-directed grasping. This evidence is limited, however, by the fact that virtually all studies have involved right-handed subjects using their dominant hand, which is presumably controlled by the left hemisphere. There is tentative evidence from earlier neurological studies that the left hemisphere may in fact play a special role in the integration of visual and motor information during grasping. We designed two experiments to test this idea. The first experiment involved pictorial illusions, which are known to have robust effects on perceptual judgments but little influence on grasping. Right- and left-handed subjects reached out and grasped objects embedded in two different visual illusions with either their dominant or their nondominant hand. For both right- and left-handed subjects, precision grasping with the left hand, but not with the right, was affected by the illusions. In a follow-up experiment, we examined precision grasping in a more natural setting and showed that left-handed subjects use their nondominant (right) hand significantly more as compared with right-handed subjects. We conclude that visuomotor mechanisms encapsulated in the left hemisphere play a crucial role in the visual control of action and that this hemispheric specialization evolved independently of handedness.
视觉引导的行动独立于视觉感知这一观点已得到神经学、神经心理学和行为学研究的支持。在健康受试者中,这种区别的证据来自于视觉错觉对感知判断和目标导向抓握影响的心理物理学研究。然而,这一证据存在局限性,因为几乎所有研究都涉及使用优势手的右利手受试者,而优势手大概由左半球控制。早期神经学研究有初步证据表明,左半球在抓握过程中视觉和运动信息的整合中可能实际上发挥着特殊作用。我们设计了两个实验来验证这一观点。第一个实验涉及图形错觉,已知其对感知判断有强烈影响,但对抓握影响很小。右利手和左利手受试者用优势手或非优势手伸手去抓握嵌入两种不同视觉错觉中的物体。对于右利手和左利手受试者来说,左手的精确抓握受到错觉影响,而右手则没有。在后续实验中,我们在更自然的环境中研究了精确抓握,并表明与右利手受试者相比,左利手受试者更多地使用非优势(右)手。我们得出结论,左半球中封装的视觉运动机制在行动的视觉控制中起着关键作用,并且这种半球特化的进化与利手无关。