Lee Seung Uk, Wykrzykowska Joanna J, Laham Roger J
Cardiovascular Division, BIDMC/Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts 02215, USA.
Toxicol Pathol. 2006;34(1):3-10. doi: 10.1080/01926230500499415.
End-stage ischemic cardiomyopathy patients are an ever-increasing group of coronary artery disease patients, often with no options in our current treatment armamentarium. Angiogenesis therapy pre-clinical and phase I clinical trials showed great promise, however, the benefits of single growth factor treatments have not been borne out in the larger phase II randomized trials. The complexity of angiogenesis process and the challenges in creating animal models to replicate and study this process in ischemic adult human myocardium have been major limitations to progress in this field. In addition failure to control for the powerful placebo effect in the clinical trials and inadequate methods of outcomes measures assessment have created difficult to overcome road blocks in establishing the efficacy of angiogenic strategies. Herein we review the challenges of angiogenesis research and development of treatment strategies. We also propose a structured model for further investigations of angiogenic therapies. The adherence to such a regimented approach as proposed here is, in our opinion, the only way to achieve success in angiogenesis approach development to treatment of patients with end-stage cardiac ischemia refractory to other established therapies.
终末期缺血性心肌病患者是冠状动脉疾病患者中数量不断增加的群体,在我们目前的治疗手段中往往没有治疗选择。血管生成疗法的临床前和I期临床试验显示出巨大前景,然而,单一生长因子治疗的益处并未在更大规模的II期随机试验中得到证实。血管生成过程的复杂性以及在缺血性成人心肌中创建用于复制和研究该过程的动物模型所面临的挑战,一直是该领域进展的主要限制因素。此外,临床试验中未能控制强大的安慰剂效应以及结局指标评估方法不足,在确立血管生成策略的疗效方面造成了难以克服的障碍。在此,我们综述了血管生成研究和治疗策略开发所面临的挑战。我们还提出了一个用于血管生成疗法进一步研究的结构化模型。我们认为,坚持本文所提出的这种严格方法是在开发血管生成疗法以治疗对其他既定疗法难治的终末期心脏缺血患者方面取得成功的唯一途径。