Hullar Timothy E
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, Missouri 63110, USA.
Anat Rec A Discov Mol Cell Evol Biol. 2006 Apr;288(4):466-72. doi: 10.1002/ar.a.20304.
The geometry of the semicircular canals has been used in evolutionary studies to predict the behaviors of extinct animals. These predictions have relied on an assumption that the responses of the canals can be determined from their dimensions, and that an organism's behavior can be determined from these responses. However, the relationship between a canal's sensitivity and its size is not well known. An intraspecies comparison among canal responses in each of three species (cat, squirrel monkey, and pigeon) was undertaken to evaluate various models of canal function and determine how their dimensions may be related to afferent physiology. All models predicted the responses of the cat afferents, but the models performed less well for squirrel monkey and pigeon. Possible causes for this discrepancy include incorrectly assuming that afferent responses accurately represent canal function or errors in current biophysical models of the canals. These findings leave open the question as to how reliably canal anatomy can be used to estimate afferent responses and how closely afferent responses are related to behavior. Other labyrinthine features, such as orientation of the horizontal canal, which is reliably held near earth-horizontal across many species, may be better to use when extrapolating the posture and related behavior of extinct animals from labyrinthine morphology.
半规管的几何形状已被用于进化研究,以预测已灭绝动物的行为。这些预测依赖于这样一种假设,即半规管的反应可以从其尺寸中确定,并且生物体的行为可以从这些反应中确定。然而,半规管的敏感性与其大小之间的关系尚不清楚。对三个物种(猫、松鼠猴和鸽子)各自的半规管反应进行了种内比较,以评估各种半规管功能模型,并确定它们的尺寸如何与传入生理学相关。所有模型都预测了猫传入神经的反应,但这些模型对松鼠猴和鸽子的表现较差。这种差异的可能原因包括错误地假设传入神经反应准确代表半规管功能,或者当前半规管生物物理模型存在误差。这些发现留下了一个问题,即半规管解剖结构能多可靠地用于估计传入神经反应,以及传入神经反应与行为的密切程度如何。其他内耳迷路特征,如水平半规管的方向,在许多物种中都可靠地保持在接近地球水平的位置,在从内耳迷路形态推断已灭绝动物的姿势和相关行为时,可能更适合使用。