Kaufman Eliezer, Epstein Joel B, Naveh Eitan, Gorsky Meir, Gross Anat, Cohen Galit
Department of Oral Medicine, Hebrew University-Hadassah, School of Dental Medicine, Jerusalem, Israel.
Anesth Prog. 2005 Winter;52(4):122-7. doi: 10.2344/0003-3006(2005)52[122:ASP]2.0.CO;2.
Intraoral local anesthesia is essential for delivering dental care. However, it is often perceived by some patients as the most painful and in some instances as the only painful part of the treatment, leading in extreme cases to avoidance of dental care. The present study measured the variables of pain, pressure, and discomfort caused by 4 commonly used local anesthesia injections: local infiltration, mental nerve block, inferior alveolar nerve block, and periodontal ligament injections. Patients were asked to grade pain, discomfort, and pressure on a visual analog scale as associated with needle insertion, operator finger position in the mouth, and pressure at injection. The inferior alveolar injection was graded to be the most painful followed by periodontal ligament and then mental nerve block injections. The periodontal ligament injections yielded the highest pressure scores. The inferior alveolar block injection yielded significantly more discomfort than local infiltration and mental nerve block injections when comparing finger and needle position. Local infiltration in the anterior maxillary region yielded the highest needle insertion and finger position discomfort scores. The present study suggests that the dental operator should be aware of local anesthesia injection pain, pressure, and discomfort together with efficacy of technique.
口腔局部麻醉对于提供牙科治疗至关重要。然而,一些患者常常认为它是最痛苦的,在某些情况下甚至是治疗中唯一痛苦的部分,在极端情况下会导致患者回避牙科治疗。本研究测量了4种常用局部麻醉注射(局部浸润、颏神经阻滞、下牙槽神经阻滞和牙周膜注射)所引起的疼痛、压力和不适变量。要求患者在视觉模拟量表上对与进针、术者手指在口腔中的位置以及注射时的压力相关的疼痛、不适和压力进行评分。下牙槽注射被评为最痛,其次是牙周膜注射,然后是颏神经阻滞注射。牙周膜注射产生的压力评分最高。比较手指和针头位置时,下牙槽阻滞注射产生的不适明显多于局部浸润和颏神经阻滞注射。上颌前部区域的局部浸润在进针和手指位置方面产生的不适评分最高。本研究表明,牙科医生应了解局部麻醉注射的疼痛、压力和不适以及技术的有效性。