Platel Hervé
EMI-E.0218 Inserm, Université de Caen, U.F.R. de Psychologie, Université de Caen, Esplanade de la Paix, 14032 Caen Cedex, France.
Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2005 Dec;1060:136-47. doi: 10.1196/annals.1360.010.
The distinction between episodic and semantic memory has become very popular since it was first proposed by Tulving in 1972. So far, very few neuropsychological, psychophysical, and imaging studies have related to the mnemonic aspects of music, notably on the long-term memory features, and practically nothing is known about the functional anatomy of long-term memory for music. Numerous functional imaging studies have shown that retrieval from semantic and episodic memory is subserved by distinct neural networks. For instance, the HERA model (hemispheric encoding/retrieval asymmetry) ascribes to the left prefrontal cortex a preferential role in the encoding process of episodic material and the recall of semantic information, while the right prefrontal cortex would preferentially operate in the recall of episodic information. However, these results were essentially obtained with verbal and visuo-spatial material. We have done a study to determine the neural substrates underlying the semantic and episodic components of music using familiar and nonfamiliar melodic tunes. Two distinct patterns of activations were found: bilateral activation of the middle and superior frontal areas and precuneus for episodic memory, and activation of the medial and orbital frontal cortex bilaterally, left angular gyrus, and the anterior part of the left middle and superior temporal gyri for semantic memory. We discuss these findings in light of the available neuropsychological data obtained in brain-damaged subjects and functional neuroimaging studies.
自1972年图尔文首次提出情景记忆和语义记忆之间的区别以来,这种区别已变得非常流行。到目前为止,很少有神经心理学、心理物理学和影像学研究涉及音乐的记忆方面,特别是关于长期记忆特征,而且实际上对于音乐长期记忆的功能解剖学几乎一无所知。众多功能影像学研究表明,语义记忆和情景记忆的提取由不同的神经网络支持。例如,HERA模型(半球编码/提取不对称)认为,左前额叶皮层在情景材料的编码过程和语义信息的回忆中起优先作用,而右前额叶皮层则在情景信息的回忆中优先发挥作用。然而,这些结果基本上是通过言语和视觉空间材料获得的。我们进行了一项研究,使用熟悉和不熟悉的旋律曲调来确定音乐语义和情景成分背后的神经基质。发现了两种不同的激活模式:情景记忆时双侧额中回和额上回以及楔前叶激活,语义记忆时双侧内侧和眶额皮层、左侧角回以及左侧颞中回和颞上回前部激活。我们根据在脑损伤患者中获得的现有神经心理学数据和功能神经影像学研究来讨论这些发现。