Kim Hyoung Soo, I Hoseok, Choi Yong Soo, Kim Kwhanmien, Shim Young Mog, Kim Jhingook
Department of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery, Hallym University Medical Center, Seoul, Korea.
J Korean Med Sci. 2006 Apr;21(2):224-8. doi: 10.3346/jkms.2006.21.2.224.
We reviewed our experience with resection of recurrent lung cancer to evaluate the benefit and risk of the procedure. From December 1994 to December 2003, 29 consecutive patients underwent pulmonary resections for recurrent lung cancer. The mean duration from the first resection to second surgery was 25.4+/-15.1 months for the definite 2nd primary lung cancer (n=20) and 8.9+/-5.7 months for metastatic lung cancer (n=9). The procedures at the second operations were completion-pneumonectomy in 11 patients, lobectomy in 5 patients, wedge resection in 12 patients and resection and anastomosis of trachea in 1 patient. Morbidity was observed in 6 (21%) of the patients and the in-hospital mortality was two patients (7%) after the repeated lung resection. Tumor recurrence after reoperation was observed in 14 patients (48%). The actuarial 5-yr survival rate was 69% and the 5-yr disease free rate following reoperation was 44%. No significant difference was found in overall survival and disease free survival between the 2nd primary lung cancer group and the metastatic lung cancer group. The recurrence rate following reoperation was significantly different between the wedge resection group and lobectomy/completion pneumonectomy group (p=0.008), but the survival rate was not significantly different (p=0.41). Surgical intervention for recurrent lung cancers can be performed with acceptable mortality and morbidity. If tolerable, completion pneumonectomy or lobectomy is recommended for resection of recurrent lung cancer.
我们回顾了复发性肺癌切除术的经验,以评估该手术的获益和风险。1994年12月至2003年12月,29例连续患者接受了复发性肺癌的肺切除术。对于明确的第二原发性肺癌(n = 20),从首次切除到第二次手术的平均时间为25.4±15.1个月,对于转移性肺癌(n = 9)为8.9±5.7个月。第二次手术的术式为全肺切除术11例、肺叶切除术5例、楔形切除术12例、气管切除吻合术1例。6例(21%)患者出现并发症,再次肺切除术后院内死亡2例(7%)。再次手术后14例(48%)患者出现肿瘤复发。精算5年生存率为69%,再次手术后5年无病生存率为44%。第二原发性肺癌组和转移性肺癌组的总生存和无病生存无显著差异。楔形切除术组与肺叶切除/全肺切除术组再次手术后的复发率有显著差异(p = 0.008),但生存率无显著差异(p = 0.41)。复发性肺癌的手术干预可在可接受死亡率和并发症发生率的情况下进行。如果可以耐受,建议行全肺切除术或肺叶切除术治疗复发性肺癌。