Oetzel G R
Department of Medical Sciences, School of Veterinary Medicine, University of Wisconsin, Madison 53706.
J Dairy Sci. 1991 Nov;74(11):3900-12. doi: 10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(91)78583-4.
Data from 75 published trials were analyzed using meta-analysis techniques (pooling of data from many trials into one analysis) to determine nutritional risk factors for milk fever. Trials included in the analysis represented 1165 cows, 214 of which developed milk fever. Prepartum dietary concentrations of S and dietary anion-cation balance [(Na + K) - (C1 + S)] were the two nutritional factors most strongly correlated to the incidence of milk fever. Logistic regression analysis revealed that dietary S had the greatest influence on the incidence of milk fever. Increasing dietary S concentrations lowered the odds ratio of developing milk fever. Increasing dietary Na and CP increased odds ratios, but to a lesser extent. Relationship of dietary Ca to milk fever was nonlinear; relative risk of milk fever was greatest at 1.16% dietary Ca (DM basis) and was lowered as dietary Ca deviated either direction from 1.16%. Except when dietary Ca was extremely high or low, effects of changes in dietary Ca on the risk of milk fever were minor. Results of the analysis clarified the influence of Ca on the relative risk for milk fever and supported the theory that anion-cation balance exerts a strong, linear effect on the incidence of this disorder.
运用荟萃分析技术(将多个试验的数据汇总到一项分析中)对75项已发表试验的数据进行分析,以确定产乳热的营养风险因素。分析中纳入的试验涉及1165头奶牛,其中214头发生产乳热。产前日粮中硫(S)的浓度以及日粮阴阳离子平衡[(钠+钾)-(氯+硫)]是与产乳热发病率相关性最强的两个营养因素。逻辑回归分析显示,日粮中的硫对产乳热发病率影响最大。提高日粮中硫的浓度会降低产生产乳热的比值比。提高日粮中钠和粗蛋白(CP)的含量会增加比值比,但影响程度较小。日粮中钙与产乳热的关系呈非线性;当日粮钙含量为1.16%(干物质基础)时,产乳热的相对风险最高,日粮钙含量偏离1.16%时,产乳热相对风险均降低。除日粮钙含量极高或极低的情况外,日粮钙含量变化对产乳热风险的影响较小。分析结果明确了钙对产乳热相对风险的影响,并支持了阴阳离子平衡对该疾病发病率有强烈线性影响的理论。