Sharma V, Chetty D N, Donde B, Mohiuddin M, Giraud A, Nayler S
Department of Radiation Oncology and Pathology, Johannesburg Hospital and University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg.
S Afr J Surg. 2006 Feb;44(1):6-8, 10-1.
To determine the impact of prognostic variables on local control in patients with aggressive fibromatosis treated with or without radiation.
Forty-two patients presenting to the combined sarcoma clinic at Johannesburg Hospital with aggressive fibromatosis from 1990 to 2003 were analysed retrospectively. There were 14 males and 28 females. The lesions involved the head and neck in 6 cases (14%), the thorax in 6 (14%), the extremities in 19 (45%) and the abdomen in 11 (26%). Thirty-seven patients (88%) presented to the clinic for the first time, whereas 5 (12%) had recurrent disease at presentation. Fifteen patients (36%) underwent excision only, 15 (36%) had excision followed by postoperative radiation, 8 (19%) had biopsy only, and 4 (9%) had radiation only. The median dose of radiation was 60 Gy (range 9 - 70 Gy).
One patient had local failure following excision and postoperative radiation therapy. The local control was 100% for surgery alone and 86% for surgery followed by postoperative radiation at > or = 24 months. On univariate analysis, age, sex, positive margins, primary or recurrent presentation, site of involvement and initial treatment did not affect local control significantly. Eight of 19 patients (42%) receiving radiation developed severe moist desquamation following treatment, and all these patients had doses of 60 Gy or more.
Surgery with or without radiation therapy gave excellent local control. The addition of radiation therapy to surgery as well as other known prognostic parameters did not impact on local control. The morbidity of radiation treatment is considerable, as noted in this series, and adjuvant radiation therapy should therefore be considered only in situations where the risk of recurrence and the morbidity of re-excision are high.
确定预后变量对接受或未接受放疗的侵袭性纤维瘤病患者局部控制的影响。
回顾性分析1990年至2003年在约翰内斯堡医院综合肉瘤门诊就诊的42例侵袭性纤维瘤病患者。其中男性14例,女性28例。病变累及头颈部6例(14%),胸部6例(14%),四肢19例(45%),腹部11例(26%)。37例(88%)患者首次到门诊就诊,5例(12%)就诊时已有复发性疾病。15例(36%)患者仅接受了切除手术,15例(36%)患者切除术后接受了放疗,8例(19%)患者仅接受了活检,4例(9%)患者仅接受了放疗。放疗的中位剂量为60 Gy(范围9 - 70 Gy)。
1例患者在切除及术后放疗后出现局部复发。单纯手术组的局部控制率为100%,切除术后放疗组在≥24个月时的局部控制率为86%。单因素分析显示,年龄、性别、切缘阳性、初次或复发表现、受累部位及初始治疗对局部控制无显著影响。19例接受放疗的患者中有8例(42%)在治疗后出现严重湿性脱皮,所有这些患者的放疗剂量均为60 Gy或更高。
手术联合或不联合放疗均能实现良好的局部控制。手术联合放疗以及其他已知的预后参数对局部控制无影响。正如本系列研究所指出的,放疗的发病率相当高,因此,仅在复发风险和再次切除的发病率较高的情况下才应考虑辅助放疗。