Higgs Gary
GIS Research Centre, School of Computing, University of Glamorgan, Pontypridd, Wales.
Waste Manag Res. 2006 Apr;24(2):105-17. doi: 10.1177/0734242X06063817.
Despite recent U.K. Government commitments' to encourage public participation in environmental decision making, those exercises conducted to date have been largely confined to 'traditional' modes of participation such as the dissemination of information and in encouraging feedback on proposals through, for example, questionnaires or surveys. It is the premise of this paper that participative approaches that use IT-based methods, based on combined geographical information systems (GIS) and multi-criteria evaluation techniques that could involve the public in the decision-making process, have the potential to build consensus and reduce disputes and conflicts such as those arising from the siting of different types of waste facilities. The potential of these techniques are documented through a review of the existing literature in order to highlight the opportunities and challenges facing decision makers in increasing the involvement of the public at different stages of the waste facility management process. It is concluded that there are important lessons to be learned by researchers, consultants, managers and decision makers if barriers hindering the wider use of such techniques are to be overcome.
尽管英国政府近期承诺鼓励公众参与环境决策,但迄今为止开展的此类活动大多局限于“传统”参与模式,如信息传播,以及通过问卷调查等方式鼓励对提案提出反馈意见。本文的前提是,基于地理信息系统(GIS)和多标准评估技术相结合的信息技术方法的参与式方法,有可能让公众参与决策过程,从而建立共识并减少争议和冲突,比如不同类型废物处理设施选址引发的冲突。通过回顾现有文献记录了这些技术的潜力,以突出决策者在废物处理设施管理过程的不同阶段增加公众参与度时面临的机遇和挑战。结论是,如果要克服阻碍此类技术更广泛应用的障碍,研究人员、顾问、管理人员和决策者都有重要经验值得借鉴。