Sätilä Heli, Kotamäki Anne, Koivikko Matti, Autti-Rämö Ilona
Department of Paediatric Neurology, Tampere University Hospital, Tampere, Finland.
Pediatr Neurol. 2006 Apr;34(4):285-90. doi: 10.1016/j.pediatrneurol.2005.08.031.
Upper limb botulinum toxin A doses in children are empirical, determined by the size of the muscle, seeking to avoid excessive weakness and deterioration of function. This study reports the effects and side effects of botulinum toxin treatment on upper limb impairment and function in 18 children with spastic or dystonic hyperactivity. A total of 54 treatments were divided into low-dose or high-dose groups according to the dose used for the target muscles. The outcome measurements included modified Ashworth Scale, passive range of movement, various grips, bimanual functions, movement pattern, House classification of upper extremity use, and subjective ratings of function and cosmetic appearance. In the functional goal group, children benefited in terms of reduction in muscle tone at elbow and wrist, and increase in passive wrist extension and House classification scores. A significant difference between the groups was observed in the House classification, favoring the low-dose group. In the nonfunctional goal group, a significant difference was detected in subjective parental cosmetic ratings, favoring the high dosage. Side effects were few and occurred mostly in the high-dose group. In conclusion, the use of higher doses in the spastic upper limb does not necessarily yield superior results compared with lower doses but increases the incidence of side effects.
儿童上肢肉毒杆菌毒素A的剂量是经验性的,由肌肉大小决定,旨在避免过度无力和功能恶化。本研究报告了肉毒杆菌毒素治疗对18例痉挛性或张力障碍性多动儿童上肢损伤和功能的影响及副作用。根据用于目标肌肉的剂量,共54次治疗被分为低剂量组或高剂量组。结果测量包括改良Ashworth量表、被动活动范围、各种抓握方式、双手功能、运动模式、上肢使用的House分类以及功能和外观的主观评分。在功能目标组中,儿童在肘部和腕部肌张力降低、被动腕部伸展增加和House分类评分方面受益。两组在House分类上存在显著差异,低剂量组更具优势。在非功能目标组中,家长对外观的主观评分存在显著差异,高剂量组更具优势。副作用较少,主要发生在高剂量组。总之,与低剂量相比,在痉挛性上肢使用高剂量不一定能产生更好的效果,但会增加副作用的发生率。