Bhatnagar S, Carey-Smith R, Darrah C, Bhatnagar P, Glasgow M M
Norfollk and Norwich University Hospital, Colney Lane, Norwich, NR4 7UY, UK.
Int Orthop. 2006 Oct;30(5):409-11. doi: 10.1007/s00264-006-0099-6. Epub 2006 Apr 27.
There has been a debate amongst orthopaedic surgeons about which plain radiographs are required in common knee conditions and this is a 5-year review assessing the influence of recent publications on the use of radiographs. A postal survey of all members of the British Orthopaedic Association was performed. The response rate was 60% (990/1,650). There was a broad agreement on the use of anteroposterior and lateral radiographs. The use of the posteroanterior (PA) weight-bearing radiograph has increased from 82 to 86%. The use of skyline view for suspected arthritis and after knee replacement has increased from 23 to 41%. There is still disparity amongst orthopaedic surgeons regarding the knee flexion angle for skyline and weight-bearing views. After review of the literature we recommend that a single skyline view in 30 degrees flexion is adequate and should be a standard investigation in knee disorders. We also stress the importance of weight-bearing PA radiograph in 30 degrees knee flexion for adequate assessment in all patients with suspected arthritis.
骨科医生们一直在争论,对于常见的膝关节疾病需要拍摄哪些普通X线片,本文是一项为期5年的综述,评估近期出版物对X线片使用的影响。对英国骨科协会的所有成员进行了邮寄调查。回复率为60%(990/1650)。对于前后位和侧位X线片的使用存在广泛共识。后前位(PA)负重X线片的使用从82%增加到了86%。用于疑似关节炎和膝关节置换术后的髌股关节切线位片的使用从23%增加到了41%。骨科医生对于髌股关节切线位片和负重位片的膝关节屈曲角度仍存在差异。在回顾文献后,我们建议30度屈曲位的单张髌股关节切线位片就足够了,并且应该成为膝关节疾病的标准检查。我们还强调,对于所有疑似关节炎的患者,30度膝关节屈曲位的负重PA X线片对于充分评估非常重要。