Kamposioras Konstantinos, Casazza Giovanni, Mauri Davide, Lakiotis Velisarios, Cortinovis Ivan, Xilomenos Apostolos, Peponi Christina, Golfinopoulos Vassilis, Milousis Athanasios, Kakaridis Dimitrios, Zacharias Georgios, Karathanasi Ioanna, Ferentinos Georgios, Proiskos Anastasios
Panhellenic Association for Continual Medical Research (PACMeR) Sections of Public-Health 28, Karolou st, 10438 Athens, Greece.
BMC Public Health. 2006 Apr 29;6:113. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-6-113.
Public health authorities worldwide discourage the use of chest radiography as a screening modality, as the diagnostic performance of chest radiography does not justify its application for screening and may even be harmful, since people with false positive results may experience anxiety and concern. Despite the accumulated evidence, various reports suggest that primary care physicians throughout the world still prescribe chest radiography for screening. We therefore set out to index the use of chest radiography for screening purposes among the healthy adult population and to analyze its relationship with possible trigger factors.
The study was designed as a cross-sectional survey. Five thousand four hundred and ninety-nine healthy adults, coming from 26 Greek provinces were surveyed for screening practice habits in the nationwide anticancer study. Data were obtained for the use of screening chest radiography. Impact of age, gender, tobacco exposure, family history positive for malignancies and professional-risk for lung diseases was further analyzed.
we found that 20% (n = 1099) of the surveyed individuals underwent chest radiography for screening purposes for at least one time during the previous three years. Among those, 24% do so with a frequency equal or higher than once yearly, and 48% with a frequency equal or higher than every three years. Screening for chest radiography was more commonly adopted among males (OR 1.130, 95% CI 0.988-1.292), pensioners (OR 1.319, CI 1.093-1.593) and individuals with a positive family history for lung cancer (OR 1.251, CI 0.988-1.583). Multivariate analysis confirmed these results.
Despite formal recommendations, chest radiography for screening purposes was a common practice among the analyzed sample of Greek adults. This practice is of questionable value since the positive predictive value of chest radiography is low. The implementation of even a relatively inexpensive imaging study on a national scale would greatly burden health economics and the workload of radiology departments.
全球公共卫生当局不鼓励将胸部X光检查用作筛查手段,因为胸部X光检查的诊断性能无法证明其用于筛查的合理性,甚至可能有害,因为假阳性结果的人可能会感到焦虑和担忧。尽管有大量证据,但各种报告表明,世界各地的初级保健医生仍会开具胸部X光检查用于筛查。因此,我们着手对健康成年人群中胸部X光检查用于筛查目的的情况进行索引,并分析其与可能的触发因素之间的关系。
该研究设计为横断面调查。在全国性抗癌研究中,对来自希腊26个省份的5499名健康成年人进行了筛查习惯调查。获取了关于使用筛查胸部X光检查的数据。进一步分析了年龄、性别、烟草暴露、恶性肿瘤家族史阳性和肺部疾病职业风险的影响。
我们发现,20%(n = 1099)的被调查个体在过去三年中至少进行过一次胸部X光检查用于筛查。其中,24%的人每年进行一次或更频繁的检查,48%的人每三年进行一次或更频繁的检查。男性(OR 1.130,95% CI 0.988 - 1.292)、退休人员(OR 1.319,CI 1.093 - 1.593)和肺癌家族史阳性的个体(OR 1.251,CI 0.988 - 1.583)更常采用胸部X光检查进行筛查。多变量分析证实了这些结果。
尽管有正式建议,但在希腊成年人的分析样本中,用于筛查目的的胸部X光检查是一种常见做法。这种做法的价值值得怀疑,因为胸部X光检查的阳性预测值较低。即使是在全国范围内实施一项相对便宜的影像学检查,也会给卫生经济学和放射科的工作量带来巨大负担。