Tatlisumak Ertugrul, Yilmaz Ovali Gulgun, Aslan Asim, Asirdizer Mahmut, Zeyfeoglu Yildiray, Tarhan Serdar
Celal Bayar University, Faculty of Medicine, Department of Anatomy, 45030 Manisa, Turkey.
Forensic Sci Int. 2007 Feb 14;166(1):42-8. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2006.03.023. Epub 2006 May 2.
The aim of the study was to define a simple system for the identification of unknown bodies by using CT images of frontal sinus and to discuss whether it was worth to add measurements to the system or not. The system was including simple features as F (presence or absence of frontal sinus), S (intersinus and intrasinus septum) and S (scalloping), and named as FSS system. Measurements selected for the study were width, height, anteroposterior length, total width of two sinuses, the distance between the highest points of the two sinuses and the distance of each sinus to its maximum lateral limit. The study was conducted retrospectively on the paranasal CT scans of 100 cases (38 male and 62 female) who had no apparent sinonasal pathology. All the features and measurements were coded according to the system defined by the authors for each case and coded formulas were compared. At least 93% of the formulas could be eliminated for a case by using FSS system. The rate of success was increased to 98% by adding measurements. Contrary to objective criteria of FSS system, measurements were prone to bias. Therefore, in practice success rate would be expected to be lower than calculated. In the study population, instead of making 100 measurements, eliminating the most of the cases with FSS system and later discriminating the rest by pattern matching was seen logical.
本研究的目的是定义一种利用额窦CT图像识别未知尸体的简单系统,并讨论是否值得在该系统中增加测量指标。该系统包括F(额窦的有无)、S(窦间和窦内间隔)和S(扇形)等简单特征,命名为FSS系统。本研究选择的测量指标有宽度、高度、前后长度、两个鼻窦的总宽度、两个鼻窦最高点之间的距离以及每个鼻窦到其最大外侧边界的距离。本研究对100例(38例男性和62例女性)无明显鼻窦病变的鼻窦CT扫描进行了回顾性分析。根据作者为每个病例定义的系统,对所有特征和测量指标进行编码,并比较编码公式。使用FSS系统,至少93% 的公式可针对某一病例被排除。通过增加测量指标,成功率提高到了98%。与FSS系统的客观标准相反,测量容易产生偏差。因此,在实际应用中,成功率预计会低于计算值。在研究人群中,与其进行100次测量,不如先用FSS系统排除大多数病例,然后通过模式匹配对其余病例进行鉴别,这样做更符合逻辑。