Duarte Paulo C, Ebel Eric D, Traub-Dargatz Josie, Wilson W David, Conrad Patricia A, Gardner Ian A
Animal Population Health Institute, College of Veterinary Medicine and Biomedical Sciences, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO 80523-1681, USA.
Am J Vet Res. 2006 May;67(5):869-76. doi: 10.2460/ajvr.67.5.869.
To assess the use of CSF testing with an indirect fluorescent antibody test (IFAT) for diagnosis of equine protozoal myeloencephalitis (EPM) caused by Sarcocystis neurona.
Test results of 428 serum and 355 CSF samples from 182 naturally exposed, experimentally infected, or vaccinated horses.
EPM was diagnosed on the basis of histologic examination of the CNS. Probability distributions were fitted to serum IFAT results in the EPM+ and EPM-horses, and correlation between serum and CSF results was modeled. Pairs of serum-CSF titers were generated by simulation, and titer-specific likelihood ratios and post-test probabilities of EPM at various pretest probability values were estimated. Post-test probabilities were compared for use of a serum-CSF test combination, a serum test only, and a CSF test only.
Post-test probabilities of EPM increased as IFAT serum and CSF titers increased. Post-test probability differences for use of a serum-CSF combination and a serum test only were < or = 19% in 95% of simulations. The largest increases occurred when serum titers were from 40 to 160 and pre-test probabilities were from 5% to 60%. In all simulations, the difference between pre- and post-test probabilities was greater for a CSF test only, compared with a serum test only.
CSF testing after a serum test has limited usefulness in the diagnosis of EPM. A CSF test alone might be used when CSF is required for other procedures. Ruling out other causes of neurologic disease reduces the necessity of additional EPM testing.
评估采用间接荧光抗体试验(IFAT)检测脑脊液用于诊断由肉孢子虫属神经元种引起的马属动物原虫性脑脊髓炎(EPM)。
来自182匹自然暴露、实验感染或接种疫苗马匹的428份血清和355份脑脊液样本的检测结果。
根据中枢神经系统的组织学检查诊断EPM。对EPM阳性和EPM阴性马匹的血清IFAT结果进行概率分布拟合,并对血清和脑脊液结果之间的相关性进行建模。通过模拟生成血清 - 脑脊液滴度对,并估计各种预测试概率值下EPM的滴度特异性似然比和测试后概率。比较使用血清 - 脑脊液联合检测、仅血清检测和仅脑脊液检测的测试后概率。
随着IFAT血清和脑脊液滴度升高,EPM的测试后概率增加。在95%的模拟中,使用血清 - 脑脊液联合检测和仅血清检测的测试后概率差异≤19%。当血清滴度为40至160且预测试概率为5%至60%时,增加幅度最大。在所有模拟中,仅脑脊液检测的测试前后概率差异比仅血清检测更大。
血清检测后进行脑脊液检测对EPM诊断的作用有限。当其他检查需要脑脊液时,可单独进行脑脊液检测。排除神经疾病的其他病因可减少额外EPM检测的必要性。