Chen Tzeng-Ji, Chou Li-Fang, Hwang Shinn-Jang
Department of Family Medicine, Taipei Veterans General Hospital, Taipei 11217, Taiwan.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2006 May 4;6:54. doi: 10.1186/1472-6963-6-54.
We used the insurance claims of a representative cohort to quantify the patterns of ambulatory care visits, especially the doctor-shopping phenomenon, in Taiwan.
The ambulatory visit files of the 200,000-person cohort datasets from the National Health Insurance Research Database in 2002 were analyzed. Only a visit with physician consultation would be considered. We computed the visit patterns both by visit count and by patient count.
In 2002, there were 182,474 eligible people with 2,443,003 physician consultations. During the year, 87.4% of the cohort had visited physician clinics and 57.5% had visited hospital-based outpatient or emergency departments. On average, a person had 13.4 physician consultations and consulted 3.4 specialties, 5.2 physicians, and 3.9 healthcare facilities in a year. In 2002, 17.3% of the cohort had ever visited different healthcare facilities on the same day; 23.5% had ever visited physicians of the same specialty at different healthcare facilities within 7 days and the percentage of second visits was 3.8% of all visits. Besides, 7.6% of the cohort had visited two or more specialties at the same facility on the same day, and such visits make up 2.5% of all visits.
The people in Taiwan did visit the physicians and outpatient departments frequently. Many patients not only consulted several physicians of different specialties and at different healthcare facilities during the year, but also switched the physicians and facilities quickly. An effective referral system with efficient data exchange between facilities might be the solution.
我们利用具有代表性队列的保险理赔数据来量化台湾地区门诊就诊模式,尤其是“找多个医生看病”的现象。
分析了2002年来自国民健康保险研究数据库的20万人队列数据集的门诊就诊档案。仅考虑有医生咨询的就诊。我们通过就诊次数和患者人数来计算就诊模式。
2002年,有182474名符合条件的人进行了2443003次医生咨询。当年,该队列中87.4%的人去过医生诊所,57.5%的人去过医院门诊或急诊科。平均而言,一个人一年有13.4次医生咨询,咨询3.4个专科、5.2名医生和3.9个医疗机构。2002年,该队列中17.3%的人曾在同一天去过不同的医疗机构;23.5%的人曾在7天内于不同医疗机构就诊于同一专科医生,二次就诊的比例占所有就诊的3.8%。此外,7.6%的队列成员曾在同一天在同一机构就诊两个或更多专科,此类就诊占所有就诊的2.5%。
台湾地区民众确实频繁就诊于医生和门诊部门。许多患者不仅在一年中咨询了不同专科、不同医疗机构的多名医生,而且还迅速更换医生和医疗机构。一个有效的转诊系统以及医疗机构之间高效的数据交换可能是解决办法。