Bonilha Leonardo, Montenegro Maria Augusta, Rorden Chris, Castellano Gabriela, Guerreiro Marilisa Mantovani, Cendes Fernando, Li Li Min
Department of Neuropsychiatry, University of South Carolina, Columbia, South Carolina, USA.
Epilepsia. 2006 May;47(5):908-15. doi: 10.1111/j.1528-1167.2006.00548.x.
Many patients with focal cortical dysplasia (FCD) continue to have seizures after surgical treatment. The usual explanation for the poor surgical outcome is the presence of residual dysplastic tissue missed by the preoperative neuroimaging investigation and therefore not resected during surgery. We apply a voxel-based morphometry (VBM) analysis to the magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans from patients with epilepsy and visually detected FCD to investigate whether (a) VBM is able to detect gray-matter concentration (GMC) abnormalities in patients with FCD, and (b) whether the extent of GMC abnormalities in the brain of these patients differs from the regions observed by using visual inspection.
We studied 11 patients with visually detected FCD (eight of them with histologic confirmation of FCD). The GMC from each one of these patients was compared with the mean GMC from a control group of 96 normal healthy subjects by using an optimized VBM protocol.
Ten of 11 patients showed statistically significant GMC excess, and among patients with GMC excess, only one showed GMC excess that was not exactly correspondent to the visually detected FCD. Seven patients exhibited excess in GMC extending beyond the area of visually detected FCD.
This preliminary neuroimaging study suggests that (a) VBM can detect GMC excess in patients with FCD, and (b) GMC excess in these patients can extend to brain areas not visually defined as abnormal. Abnormal areas detected by VBM can possibly correspond to mild malformations of cortical development, supporting the notion that the surgical refractoriness observed in patients with FCD can be due to the incomplete resection of the dysplastic tissue.
许多局灶性皮质发育不良(FCD)患者在手术治疗后仍有癫痫发作。手术效果不佳的常见解释是术前神经影像学检查遗漏了残留的发育异常组织,因此在手术中未被切除。我们对癫痫患者和视觉检测到的FCD患者的磁共振成像(MRI)扫描应用基于体素的形态计量学(VBM)分析,以研究(a)VBM是否能够检测FCD患者的灰质浓度(GMC)异常,以及(b)这些患者大脑中GMC异常的范围是否与通过视觉检查观察到的区域不同。
我们研究了11例视觉检测到FCD的患者(其中8例经组织学证实为FCD)。通过使用优化的VBM方案,将这些患者中每一位的GMC与96名正常健康受试者的对照组的平均GMC进行比较。
11例患者中有10例显示出统计学上显著的GMC增加,在GMC增加的患者中,只有1例显示的GMC增加与视觉检测到的FCD不完全对应。7例患者的GMC增加超出了视觉检测到的FCD区域。
这项初步的神经影像学研究表明,(a)VBM可以检测FCD患者的GMC增加,(b)这些患者的GMC增加可以扩展到视觉上未定义为异常的脑区。VBM检测到的异常区域可能对应于皮质发育的轻度畸形,支持了FCD患者手术难治性可能是由于发育异常组织切除不完全的观点。