Ozalp Taçkin, Yercan Hüseyin, Okçu Güvenir, Ozdemir Oğuz, Coşkunol Erhan
Celal Bayar Universitesi Tip Fakültesi Ortopedi ve Travmatoloji Anabilim Dali.
Acta Orthop Traumatol Turc. 2006;40(2):144-50.
We evaluated patients who underwent surgical treatment for giant cell tumor of the wrist with regard to recurrence rates, factors influencing tumor recurrence, complications, and postoperative functional and emotional status of the patients.
The study included 23 patients (6 males, 17 females; mean age 31.6 years; range 12 to 74 years) who were treated surgically for giant cell tumor of the wrist. Grading, assessment of surgical margins, and functional evaluation were performed according to the Enneking's criteria. The effects of tumor volume, soft tissue extension, and selected surgical therapy on recurrence were investigated. Joint movements and stability, postoperative pain, presence of deformity, muscle strength, limitations in functional activities, and patient satisfaction were evaluated. The mean follow-up period was 6.7 years.
Of all the patients, 69% had stage 2 and 23% had stage 3 tumors. There was no significant correlation between tumor volume and recurrence (p=0.22). Recurrences were observed in three (33%) of nine patients with soft tissue extension and in four (28.6%) of 14 patients without soft tissue extension. Recurrence rates were 33.3% in those who were treated by curettage alone (n=3), 50% with curettage and grafting (n=6), 50% with curettage and bone cement (n=2), and 16% in those who underwent wide excision (n=12).
The most important factor influencing recurrence rate in giant cell tumors is the extent of surgical resection. At least marginal resection must be considered in patients with stage 2 and 3 lesions especially in cases with soft tissue extension. Adjunctive therapy should be added if curettage is considered.
我们评估了接受腕部骨巨细胞瘤手术治疗的患者的复发率、影响肿瘤复发的因素、并发症以及患者术后的功能和情绪状况。
该研究纳入了23例接受腕部骨巨细胞瘤手术治疗的患者(6例男性,17例女性;平均年龄31.6岁;范围12至74岁)。根据Enneking标准进行分级、手术切缘评估和功能评估。研究肿瘤体积、软组织侵犯范围和所选手术治疗对复发的影响。评估关节活动度和稳定性、术后疼痛、畸形情况、肌肉力量、功能活动受限情况以及患者满意度。平均随访时间为6.7年。
所有患者中,69%为2期肿瘤,23%为3期肿瘤。肿瘤体积与复发之间无显著相关性(p = 0.22)。9例有软组织侵犯的患者中有3例(33%)复发,14例无软组织侵犯的患者中有4例(28.6%)复发。单纯刮除术治疗的患者复发率为33.3%(n = 3),刮除术加植骨的患者复发率为50%(n = 6),刮除术加骨水泥的患者复发率为50%(n = 2),广泛切除术治疗的患者复发率为16%(n = 12)。
影响骨巨细胞瘤复发率的最重要因素是手术切除范围。对于2期和3期病变患者,尤其是有软组织侵犯的病例,至少应考虑边缘切除。如果考虑刮除术,应加用辅助治疗。