Qu Peng, Wang Chunsheng, Shen Gary X
Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam, Hong Kong.
J Magn Reson Imaging. 2006 Jul;24(1):248-55. doi: 10.1002/jmri.20620.
To develop a novel regularization method for GRAPPA by which the regularization parameters can be optimally and adaptively chosen.
In the fit procedures in GRAPPA, the discrepancy principle, which chooses the regularization parameter based on a priori information about the noise level in the autocalibrating signals (ACS), is used with the truncated singular value decomposition (TSVD) regularization and the Tikhonov regularization, and its performance is compared with the singular value (SV) threshold method and the L-curve method, respectively by axial and sagittal head imaging experiments.
In both axial and sagittal reconstructions, normal GRAPPA reconstruction results exhibit a relatively high level of noise. With discrepancy-based choices of parameters, regularization can improve the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) with only a very modest increase in aliasing artifacts. The L-curve method in all of the reconstructions leads to overregularization, which causes severe residual aliasing artifacts. The 10% SV threshold method yields good overall image quality in the axial case, but in the sagittal case it also leads to an obvious increase in aliasing artifacts.
Neither a fixed SV threshold nor the L-curve are robust means of choosing the appropriate parameters in GRAPPA reconstruction. However, with the discrepancy-based parameter-choice strategy, adaptively regularized GRAPPA can be used to automatically choose nearly optimal parameters for reconstruction and achieve an excellent compromise between SNR and artifacts.
开发一种用于GRAPPA的新型正则化方法,通过该方法可以最优地、自适应地选择正则化参数。
在GRAPPA的拟合过程中,基于关于自校准信号(ACS)中噪声水平的先验信息选择正则化参数的差异原则,与截断奇异值分解(TSVD)正则化和Tikhonov正则化一起使用,并分别通过轴向和矢状面头部成像实验将其性能与奇异值(SV)阈值法和L曲线法进行比较。
在轴向和矢状面重建中,常规GRAPPA重建结果均表现出相对较高的噪声水平。通过基于差异的参数选择,正则化可以提高信噪比(SNR),同时混叠伪影仅略有增加。在所有重建中,L曲线法都会导致过度正则化,从而产生严重的残余混叠伪影。10% SV阈值法在轴向情况下可产生良好的整体图像质量,但在矢状面情况下也会导致混叠伪影明显增加。
固定的SV阈值和L曲线都不是在GRAPPA重建中选择合适参数的稳健方法。然而,采用基于差异的参数选择策略,自适应正则化的GRAPPA可用于自动选择近乎最优的重建参数,并在SNR和伪影之间实现出色的平衡。