Ferrão Ygor A, Shavitt Roseli G, Bedin Nádia R, de Mathis Maria Eugênia, Carlos Lopes Antônio, Fontenelle Leonardo F, Torres Albina R, Miguel Eurípedes C
Department of Psychiatry, University of São Paulo Medical School, São Paulo, Brazil.
J Affect Disord. 2006 Aug;94(1-3):199-209. doi: 10.1016/j.jad.2006.04.019. Epub 2006 Jun 9.
Some patients with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) exhibit an unsatisfactory reduction in symptom severity despite being treated with all the available therapeutic alternatives. The clinical variables associated with treatment-refractoriness in OCD are inconsistently described in the literature.
To investigate factors associated with treatment-refractoriness of patients with OCD, we conducted a case-control study, comparing 23 patients with treatment-refractory OCD to 26 patients with treatment-responding OCD.
The factors associated with refractoriness of OCD were higher severity of symptoms since the onset of OCD (p<0.001), chronic course (p=0.003), lack of a partner (p=0.037), unemployment (p=0.025), low economic status (p=0.015), presence of obsessive-compulsive symptoms of sexual/religious content (p=0.043), and higher scores on family accommodation (p<0.001). Only the three latter variables remained significantly associated with treatment-refractoriness after regression analyses.
small sample size, the biases and drawbacks inherent to a case-control study, and the inclusion criteria used to define the study groups may have limited the generalisation of the results.
A major strength of this study is the systematic and structured evaluation of a vast array of variables related to the clinical expression of OCD, including epigenetic factors and ratings derived from instruments evaluating family accommodation. The presence of sexual/religious symptoms, low economic status and high modification on family function due to OCD were independently associated with treatment-refractoriness. Future longitudinal studies are warranted to verify if these variables represent predictive factors of treatment non-response.
一些强迫症(OCD)患者尽管接受了所有可用的治疗方案,但症状严重程度仍未得到令人满意的减轻。文献中对与强迫症治疗难治性相关的临床变量描述并不一致。
为了研究与强迫症患者治疗难治性相关的因素,我们进行了一项病例对照研究,将23例治疗难治性强迫症患者与26例治疗有反应的强迫症患者进行比较。
与强迫症难治性相关的因素包括强迫症发病以来症状的更高严重程度(p<0.001)、病程慢性(p=0.003)、没有伴侣(p=0.037)、失业(p=0.025)、经济状况差(p=0.015)、存在性/宗教内容的强迫症状(p=0.043)以及家庭迁就得分较高(p<0.001)。回归分析后,只有后三个变量仍与治疗难治性显著相关。
样本量小、病例对照研究固有的偏差和缺陷,以及用于定义研究组的纳入标准可能限制了结果的普遍性。
本研究的一个主要优势是对与强迫症临床表达相关的大量变量进行了系统和结构化的评估,包括表观遗传因素以及评估家庭迁就的工具得出的评分。性/宗教症状的存在、经济状况差以及强迫症对家庭功能的高度改变与治疗难治性独立相关。未来有必要进行纵向研究,以验证这些变量是否代表治疗无反应的预测因素。