Rosted Palle, Andersen Claus
Sheffield Universitet, Sheffield, England.
Ugeskr Laeger. 2006 May 15;168(20):1982-6.
Stimulation techniques (SB) include manipulation, acupuncture, acupressure, physiotherapy, transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation, reflexotherapy, laser treatment and epidural stimulation technique. The purpose of this paper is to investigate the scientific evidence for these techniques. The Cochrane Library and Medline were searched for all techniques from 2000 to date. Only randomised controlled studies written in English were included. Search words were used, such as; acupuncture and neck pain, shoulder pain, etc. In total 587 papers were identified for the following diseases; headache, neck pain, shoulder pain, elbow pain, low back pain and knee pain. 415 papers were excluded, and the remaining 172 papers, a total of 20,431 patients, are the basis for this study. The effect of acupuncture and epidural stimulation technique is scientifically well-supported. For the remaining techniques, the scientific evidence is dubious.
刺激技术(SB)包括手法治疗、针灸、指压、物理治疗、经皮电刺激神经疗法、反射疗法、激光治疗和硬膜外刺激技术。本文旨在研究这些技术的科学证据。检索了Cochrane图书馆和Medline中2000年至今的所有相关技术。仅纳入用英文撰写的随机对照研究。使用了如“针灸与颈部疼痛”“肩部疼痛”等检索词。总共识别出587篇关于以下疾病的论文:头痛、颈部疼痛、肩部疼痛、肘部疼痛、下背部疼痛和膝盖疼痛。排除了415篇论文,其余172篇论文,共涉及20431名患者,是本研究的基础。针灸和硬膜外刺激技术的效果在科学上有充分支持。对于其余技术,科学证据存疑。