Brand Richard A, Hannafin Jo A
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, The University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA, USA.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2006 Aug;449:67-71. doi: 10.1097/01.blo.0000224035.08603.18.
The number of clinician-scientists has declined over the past several decades and evidence suggests this trend also applies to orthopaedic surgery. A previous study identified only 64 principle investigator orthopaedic surgeons with over 100,000 dollars of NIH funding from 1992 to 2001, during which funding declined for orthopaedic surgeons. We surveyed 58 of these 64 surgeons (six were retired) to ascertain aspects of their environment that might lead to success and what obstacles they encountered. The common definition of a clinician-scientist was an individual who obtained external funding for research. With a response rate of 79%, 26 of 40 (65%) began their research careers before residency. Nearly half had additional specialized training in research and most thought at least 6 months training was important. Thirty four of 46 respondents (74%) percent spent less than 20% of their time in research but 43 of 45 (95%) thought at least 30% ideal. Twenty five of 43 (58%) had unshared laboratory space and those without typically share with three or more scientists. Twenty eight of 43 (65%) believed their level of external funding adequate. Twenty of 46 (43%) believed their colleagues resented the time they spent in research. Demands on clinical time continue to be a major impediment to orthopaedic clinician-scientists. The orthopaedic community must develop supportive environments for clinician-scientists.
在过去几十年中,临床科学家的数量有所减少,有证据表明这种趋势也适用于骨科手术领域。先前的一项研究发现,在1992年至2001年期间,只有64名主要研究者身份的骨科外科医生获得了超过10万美元的美国国立卫生研究院(NIH)资助,在此期间,骨科外科医生获得的资助有所下降。我们对这64名外科医生中的58名(6名已退休)进行了调查,以确定他们所处环境中可能促成成功的因素以及他们遇到的障碍。临床科学家的普遍定义是获得外部研究资金的个人。回复率为79%,40名受访者中有26名(65%)在住院医师培训之前就开始了他们的研究职业生涯。近一半的人接受了额外的研究专业培训,大多数人认为至少6个月的培训很重要。46名受访者中有34名(74%)将不到20%的时间用于研究,但45名受访者中有43名(95%)认为至少30%的时间才理想。43名受访者中有25名(58%)没有独立的实验室空间,而没有独立空间的人通常与三名或更多科学家共用。43名受访者中有28名(65%)认为他们获得的外部资金水平足够。46名受访者中有20名(43%)认为他们的同事对他们花在研究上的时间不满。临床工作时间的需求仍然是骨科临床科学家面临的主要障碍。骨科界必须为临床科学家营造支持性的环境。