Verucci L, Menghini D, Vicari S
Ospedale Pediatrico Bambino Gesù, IRCCS, Rome, Italy.
J Intellect Disabil Res. 2006 Jul;50(Pt 7):477-91. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2788.2006.00793.x.
Although reading abilities play a fundamental role in the acquisition of personal autonomy, up until now studies investigating these abilities in Down syndrome (DS) are aimed at defining educational or rehabilitation acquisition. However, studies describing the relationship between reading and phonological awareness in individuals with DS by comparing them to typically developing children often report contradictory results. The aim of this study is to explore reading and phonological awareness skills in a group of participants with DS.
We administered reading and phonological processing ability tests to 17 DS individuals and to 17 reading-age-matched typically developing children.
Concerning reading abilities, participants with DS were impaired on non-word reading and on interpreting accuracy of non-homographic homophones. Their passage comprehension was also limited. Comparable ability was reported in the two groups on irregular word reading and passage reading tasks. Regarding phonological awareness ability, individuals with DS showed lower performances on several tasks, such as rhyming, deletion and syllable segmentation.
People with DS show particular failure on non-word reading, a task where correct decoding is only partially influenced by lexical access or semantic context. Correct non-word reading mainly requires the use of the grapheme-phoneme conversion process. This process is based on the efficiency of phonological awareness abilities, which are partly impaired in people with DS. The rehabilitative implications of these findings are discussed.
尽管阅读能力在个人自主性的获得中起着基础性作用,但到目前为止,针对唐氏综合征(DS)患者阅读能力的研究旨在确定教育或康复方面的收获。然而,通过将DS患者与正常发育儿童进行比较来描述阅读与语音意识之间关系的研究,结果往往相互矛盾。本研究的目的是探索一组DS患者的阅读和语音意识技能。
我们对17名DS患者和17名阅读年龄匹配的正常发育儿童进行了阅读和语音处理能力测试。
在阅读能力方面,DS患者在非单词阅读和非同形同音词解释准确性方面存在缺陷。他们的篇章理解能力也有限。在不规则单词阅读和篇章阅读任务中,两组表现相当。在语音意识能力方面,DS患者在押韵、删除和音节分割等多项任务中表现较差。
DS患者在非单词阅读方面表现出特别的困难,在这项任务中,正确解码仅部分受词汇通达或语义语境的影响。正确的非单词阅读主要需要运用音素-音位转换过程。这个过程基于语音意识能力的效率,而DS患者的语音意识能力部分受损。本文讨论了这些发现的康复意义。