Wenger J D, Pierce R, Deaver K A, Plikaytis B D, Facklam R R, Broome C V
Meningitis and Special Pathogens Branch, Centers for Disease Control, Atlanta, Georgia 30333.
Lancet. 1991 Aug 17;338(8764):395-8.
Vaccines prepared from the polyribosylribitol phosphate (PRP) capsule of Haemophilus influenzae b (Hib) have not consistently shown good efficacy in protecting children aged over 18 months from invasive Hib disease. To evaluate the efficacy of conjugate-PRP vaccines in this age-group, and to compare their effect with that of PRP vaccines, a post-marketing case-control study was conducted among 10,400,000 persons. Between Oct 1, 1988, and Feb 28, 1990, 75 patients with Hib disease and 161 control children between 18 and 60 months of age were enrolled. To minimise potentially confounding socioeconomic variables, controls were selected either from among patients' classmates at their day-care centre or from among family acquaintances. 9 of the 75 patients had received the diphtheria toxoid conjugate Hib vaccine more than 2 weeks before onset of illness. After adjusting for age and household crowding, the efficacy of PRP Hib vaccine was 64% (95% Cl = -20,89) and efficacy of the diphtheria toxoid conjugate Hib vaccine was 74% (95% Cl = 30,90). The study shows that the protective efficacy of this conjugate vaccine is less than ideal and highlights the need for additional post-licensing studies to confirm and expand understanding of the efficacy of these new products.
由b型流感嗜血杆菌(Hib)的多聚核糖醇磷酸酯(PRP)荚膜制备的疫苗,在保护18个月以上儿童免受侵袭性Hib疾病方面,并未始终显示出良好的疗效。为评估结合型PRP疫苗在该年龄组中的疗效,并将其效果与PRP疫苗进行比较,开展了一项针对1040万人的上市后病例对照研究。在1988年10月1日至1990年2月28日期间,招募了75例Hib疾病患者和161名18至60个月大的对照儿童。为尽量减少潜在的社会经济混杂变量,对照儿童从患者日托中心的同学或家庭熟人中选取。75例患者中有9例在发病前2周以上接种了白喉类毒素结合型Hib疫苗。在对年龄和家庭拥挤程度进行调整后,PRP Hib疫苗的疗效为64%(95%可信区间=-20,89),白喉类毒素结合型Hib疫苗的疗效为74%(95%可信区间=30,90)。该研究表明,这种结合疫苗的保护效果并不理想,并突出了在获得许可后进行更多研究以确认和扩大对这些新产品疗效理解的必要性。